Hello, this is Ryuta Hamamoto from TIMEWELL.
(November 22, 2026) Our description of the SME FDP rule exclusion (§742.4(a)(4)(ii)(B)) left out three conditions: it covers only items subject to the EAR under §734.4(a)(8) or §734.9(k), only reexports and exports from abroad, and requires that the ultimate parent company also not be headquartered in D:5 or Macau. We have added them as the regulation states.
"We made it in a Japanese plant, with Japanese staff, for a Japan-domestic deal. Why do U.S. export controls still matter?" I hear that question from export-control teams all the time. The answer is usually the Foreign Direct Product Rule (FDPR).
FDPR is how the United States extends the Export Administration Regulations (EAR) beyond U.S. territory. Since the 2020 Huawei-related measures, it has become a core tool of U.S. China- and Russia-related export controls, and new variants have been added almost every year. Semiconductor makers, equipment makers, trading houses, and logistics providers in Japan are all in the picture, and so are U.S. companies that buy from them. One note before we start: Entity List placement is a regulatory designation under U.S. rules. It is not a judgment on the company listed.
Teams still mix up FDPR with the similar-but-different de minimis rule, or assume that "no U.S. parts" means they are safe. The opposite mistake happens too: treating every FDPR variant as if it applied to shipments from Japan, including the ones that carve Japan out, and stopping deals that could have gone ahead. Below I rebuild FDPR from the regulation itself, contrast it with de minimis, walk through the variants, and flag where Japanese suppliers actually get caught. This is general information, not legal advice.
The short version (as of November 20, 2026): FDPR lives in 15 CFR 734.9, which contains 10 rule types, paragraphs (b) through (k). The interim final rule effective November 19, 2026 (91 FR 74970) removed paragraph (l), the AI model weights FDP rule.1 De minimis asks what share of a product is controlled U.S.-origin content. FDPR asks whether the product is the direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, or was made in a plant or by major equipment that is itself such a direct product. For shipments from Japan, the main variants with no carve-out are the Entity List FDP rules for Footnotes 1 and 4 and the advanced computing FDP rule. The Russia/Belarus rules exclude shipments from Japan, and the semiconductor-equipment rules (SME and Footnote 5) carve out Japan as well. The AI Diffusion Rule was formally rescinded by the November 19, 2026 rule, which also removed (l) and 4E091 and rewrote the destinations for the advanced computing license requirement (five countries: Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brazil and Thailand; plus D:1, D:4 and D:5 excluding A:5 and A:6, and the UAE). The language extending the FDP rules to 50%-owned affiliates is stayed; on November 9, 2026 BIS extended the stay through January 10, 2027 (91 FR 70789; updated November 20, 2026). If you want a quick read on where your own program stands, our three-minute export compliance check is a reasonable place to start.
What you will learn
- How FDPR is structured, and why extraterritorial reach works
- The core difference between de minimis ("content ratio") and FDPR ("U.S. technology and tools")
- The 10 rule types in the regulation (the 11th, AI model weights, was removed on November 19, 2026), and the families that matter in practice
- The exclusions that apply to shipments from Japan (Russia, SME, Footnote 5), and where they stop
- Why the AI Diffusion Rule's text is still on the books, and what BIS actually enforces
- What a published $300 million settlement says about FDPR "knowledge"
- Five practical steps for your compliance program
What FDPR is: three terms first
FDPR brings a foreign-made item under the EAR when it is the "direct product" of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, or when it was produced by a complete plant or a "major component" of a plant that is itself such a direct product. Section 734.3(a)(4), which defines what is subject to the EAR, points to the foreign-produced direct products described in 734.9, and 734.9 sets out which combinations qualify.23 Three terms are worth pinning down.
1. EAR (Export Administration Regulations) The Commerce Department's BIS rules at 15 CFR Parts 730–774. Japan's equivalent framework, the Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act (FEFTA), focuses on goods and technology leaving Japan. The EAR can also pull in items made outside the United States, through FDPR and de minimis.
2. Direct product A foreign-produced item made directly using U.S.-origin technology or software. FDPR covers those direct products, and it also covers items made in a plant, or by major equipment, that is itself a direct product. The regulation's definition of "major component" includes testing equipment.3
3. De minimis In export control, de minimis means that if the controlled U.S.-origin content in a foreign-made item exceeds a value threshold, the whole foreign item is treated as subject to the EAR. "Controlled" means U.S.-origin content that would need a license if shipped from the United States to that destination, so EAR99 parts drop out of the numerator for most destinations. The threshold is 25% for most destinations and 10% for Country Groups E:1 and E:2, which in the eCFR as of October 2026 means Cuba, Iran, North Korea, and Syria.4 For the arithmetic, see our EAR99 and de minimis guide; for finding ECCNs, see what an ECCN is and how to look one up. FDPR runs on completely different logic.
FDPR ("U.S. technology and tools") vs de minimis ("content ratio")
This is the heart of the topic. Mix these two up and the classification work downstream goes wrong.
| Dimension | De minimis | FDPR |
|---|---|---|
| What it looks at | Value share of controlled U.S.-origin content built into the product | Whether the product is a direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, or was made in a plant or by major equipment that is itself such a direct product |
| Threshold | Above 25% (above 10% for E:1 and E:2) | No percentage; a link to the technology or software ECCNs the rule specifies |
| Calculation | Value-based ratio | Yes or no |
| Typical example | Japanese equipment containing a U.S. part that needs a license for the destination | Chips made on a line whose tools were built from U.S.-origin technology |
| Path into the EAR | Content | Production process |
Put simply, de minimis asks how much controlled U.S. content is inside. FDPR asks where the tools and the recipe came from.
The critical point: you can be caught by FDPR with zero U.S. content. "We do not use U.S. parts" is no answer if the production equipment meets the rule. That is still the blind spot I run into most often with Japanese manufacturers.
There is a detail in the text that is easy to miss. The plant condition is not "made in the U.S." The regulation covers a plant or major component "whether made in the U.S. or a foreign country," as long as it is itself a direct product of the specified U.S.-origin technology or software.3 A Japanese-built tool can be the starting point if it was built from U.S.-origin technology, and what matters is where the tool's technology came from rather than its country of manufacture. My practical advice: assume leading U.S.-built equipment meets the condition and start there, then ask Japanese and European tool vendors directly.
FDPR analysis generally runs through three questions (exact conditions vary by rule):
- Product scope. Is the item a direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, or made in a plant or by major equipment that is? Some rules also require the item itself to fall under particular ECCNs.
- Destination or end-user scope. Is it headed to a covered country, or is an Entity List party with a particular footnote involved in the transaction?
- Knowledge. Did the exporter know, or have reason to know, about that destination or party?
One point that surprises people: the Entity List FDP rules for Footnotes 1 and 4 do not care how the product itself is classified.3 A general-purpose item that appears nowhere on the CCL can still be caught if the production link exists and a footnoted party is involved. The $300 million settlement I describe below involved hard disk drives.
The two rules also overlap in one place. Since December 2024, there is no de minimis level at all for certain semiconductor manufacturing equipment that contains a U.S.-origin integrated circuit and is headed to Macau, a Country Group D:5 destination, or a Footnote 5 entity (734.4(a)(8) and (a)(9)).4 For that equipment, the "we fall under the percentage" exit is closed from the start.
A form for recording de minimis and FDP judgments, item by item. We publish a working checklist that follows the order of review: is the item subject to the EAR, does it match an ECCN on the CCL, or does it fall to EAR99. It has fields for the embargo, end-use, and end-user checks, the de minimis and foreign direct product (FDP) judgments, and the cross-check against Japan's classification, so a completed sheet doubles as your internal record. Download the EAR Classification Flow & EAR99 Checklist (2026) for free.
Replace siloed classification work with AI.
METI's FY2024 data shows 52% of foreign exchange law violations stem from classification errors. Download the TRAFEED product catalog covering features and rollout.
The FDP rules: five families and the paragraphs (AI model weights removed on November 19, 2026)
All FDP rules sit in 734.9, but the text splits into 10 paragraphs, (b) through (k), each with its own scope (paragraph (l) was removed by the November 19, 2026 rule).3 BIS consolidated the scattered provisions into 734.9 in February 2022 and has been adding paragraphs since.5 Here is the full map.
| Paragraph | Rule | Main scope | Introduced | Carve-out for shipments from Japan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (b) | National Security FDP | Direct products of national-security-controlled technology that requires a written assurance, where the product is also NS-controlled; to D:1, E:1, E:2 | Long-standing | None |
| (c) | 9x515 FDP | Spacecraft-related 9x515 items; to D:5, E:1, E:2 | Long-standing | None |
| (d) | "600 series" FDP | Military "600 series" items; to D:1, D:3, D:4, D:5, E:1, E:2 | Long-standing | None |
| (e)(1) | Entity List FDP, Footnote 1 | Transactions involving Footnote 1 entities; product classification irrelevant | May 2020, expanded August 2020 | None |
| (e)(2) | Entity List FDP, Footnote 4 | Transactions involving Footnote 4 entities; product classification irrelevant | October 2022 | None |
| (e)(3) | Entity List FDP, Footnote 5 | Semiconductor equipment to Footnote 5 entities or advanced-node fabs in D:5 or Macau | December 2024 | No license requirement when a company headquartered in Japan ships from Japan |
| (f) | Russia/Belarus FDP | CCL items and more to Russia, Belarus, occupied Crimea | February–March 2022 | Shipments from Japan excluded |
| (g) | Russia/Belarus Military End User and Procurement FDP | Transactions involving Footnote 3 entities | February 2022 | Shipments from Japan excluded |
| (h) | Advanced computing FDP | 3A090, 4A090, and related advanced chips and computers | October 2022; expanded November 2023 and January 2025 | None |
| (i) | "Supercomputer" FDP | Supercomputers in China or Macau | October 2022 | None |
| (j) | Iran FDP | Iran | February 2023 | Shipments from Japan excluded (746.7) |
| (k) | SME FDP | Certain semiconductor equipment to D:5 or Macau | December 2024 | Excluded for entities located in Japan that are not headquartered in D:5 or Macau |
| (l) | AI model weights FDP | ECCN 4E091 (model weights) | January 2025 | Removed by the November 19, 2026 rule (91 FR 74970); ECCN 4E091 also removed from the CCL |
I checked the carve-out column against the eCFR as of October 1, 2026.678 "None" means a license can be required even for shipments from Japan, so each transaction still has to be run against the rule's conditions. These are the families that matter most in practice (the fifth, the AI model weights rule, is kept as a record of how it was removed on November 19, 2026).
1. Entity List FDP rules (734.9(e))
These apply to Entity List parties that carry a particular footnote, and the footnote number sets the scope.
- Footnote 1: mainly Huawei-related entities. Introduced May 15, 2020 and significantly expanded on August 17, 2020
- Footnote 4: advanced computing and supercomputer-related. Applied in October 2022 to 28 entities in China that were already on the list9
- Footnote 5: advanced-node semiconductor production. Applied in December 2024 to 16 entities, nine newly added and seven already listed.10 The eCFR as of October 1, 2026 still shows 16 Footnote 5 entries
Earlier versions of this article described Footnote 3 as "military end users" generally. That was not accurate. Footnote 3 marks Russian or Belarusian military end users and procurement entities supplying those countries' defense industry or intelligence services, and it ties to the Russia/Belarus military end user FDP rule in paragraph (g).3
Listing alone does not trigger FDPR; listing plus the relevant footnote does. Also note that the Affiliates Rule published September 30, 2025 (90 FR 47201) added language extending the end-user scope of paragraphs (e) and (g) to foreign entities owned 50% or more, in aggregate, by covered parties.11 That language was stayed by the suspension rule (90 FR 50857), originally through November 9, 2026.12 On November 9, BIS published a final rule extending the stay through January 10, 2027, effective the same day (91 FR 70789).[^fr70789] The United States and China had announced that their arrangement, including this pause, would run to January 10, 2027 (China's Ministry of Commerce stated it in an official briefing on September 28;13 the U.S. Treasury Secretary's September 23 remarks are known through press reports14); the Federal Register now backs that up. I track the deadline and the extension in our BIS 50% rule (Affiliates Rule) guide.
2. Advanced computing FDP rule (734.9(h))
Created October 7, 2022 for advanced computing items: ECCN 3A090 and 4A090 chips and computers and related ".z" items.9 The destination scope started with China and Macau, then from November 17, 2023 covered Country Groups D:1, D:4, and D:5 (excluding countries also in A:5 or A:6) plus entities headquartered in D:5 or Macau.15
The January 2025 AI Diffusion Rule rewrote the destination scope in (h) to "any location worldwide," and the November 19, 2026 rule kept that scope ((h)(2)(i)).3161 The FDP rule decides whether a foreign-made item is subject to the EAR; whether a license is needed is set elsewhere. Before November 19, BIS said in its July 14, 2026 rule on the UAE and its May 31, 2026 guidance that it was enforcing the advanced computing license requirement only for D:1, D:4 and D:5 (excluding A:5 and A:6) and for entities headquartered in D:5 or Macau.1718 The text itself has now changed. The November 19 rule (91 FR 74970) rewrote §742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A): a license is now required under (A)(1) for Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brazil and Thailand (consignees and end users headquartered in the U.S. are excluded if the §743.10 reporting is met) and under (A)(2) for D:1, D:4 and D:5 (excluding A:5 and A:6) and the UAE. For the UAE, no license is required when the ultimate consignee and all end users are approved UAE entities listed in Supplement No. 8 to Part 740 and specified as approved to receive these items. Entities headquartered in D:5 or Macau are caught by §744.23(a)(3)(i)(A).1
Separately, on January 15, 2026 BIS changed the license review policy for Nvidia H200-class and less advanced chips to China and Macau from a presumption of denial to case-by-case review (91 FR 1684).19 That is a review-policy change. The reach of FDPR did not change.
3. Russia/Belarus FDP rules (734.9(f) and (g))
Created February 24, 2022, after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and extended to Belarus in March 2022.3 They also cover the temporarily occupied Crimea region. Product scope is very wide: any item under an ECCN on the CCL, plus items listed in supplements 6 and 7 to part 746.
There is an important carve-out for Japan. Supplement 3 to part 746 lists countries that have committed to substantially similar export controls on Russia and Belarus under their own laws, and exports and reexports from those countries are excluded from the license requirements tied to paragraphs (f) and (g) (746.8(a)(12)(iii)).8 Japan has been listed with a full exclusion since March 2022. For shipments from Japan, the binding rules are Japan's own measures on Russia under FEFTA, not the U.S. FDP rules. Other EAR provisions, such as reexports of U.S.-origin items themselves, still need their own check. The trap is the overseas subsidiary.
4. Footnote 5 and SME FDP rules (December 2024)
Covered in its own section below. These target semiconductor manufacturing equipment and came in the same package as the HBM (high bandwidth memory) controls.
5. AI model weights FDP rule (734.9(l), January 2025; removed November 19, 2026)
Updated November 20, 2026: this rule was removed by the interim final rule effective November 19, 2026 (91 FR 74970). The amendatory instruction reads "Amend Sec. 734.9 by removing paragraph (l)," and ECCN 4E091 was removed from the CCL.1 What follows is a record of how it got there.
Also covered below. This was the first rule to control AI model weights. BIS said in May 2025 it would not enforce it, and the November 19, 2026 rule removed it from the text.1
Underneath all of this sits paragraph (b), the National Security FDP rule. It catches direct products of national-security-controlled U.S.-origin technology or software that requires a written assurance for licensing, where the product itself is NS-controlled, when headed to Country Groups D:1, E:1, or E:2.3
Footnote 5 and the SME FDP rule (December 2024): what changed for equipment makers
On December 2, 2024 (published December 5), BIS significantly tightened semiconductor controls.1510 The package had three main parts:
- HBM added to the CCL as ECCN 3A090.c
- Two new FDP rules: paragraph (e)(3), tied to Entity List Footnote 5, and paragraph (k), the SME FDP rule for certain equipment headed to D:5 or Macau
- Expanded SME controls on etch, deposition, lithography, and related process tools
The Footnote 5 rule covers semiconductor equipment under 3B001, 3B002, 3B903, 3B991, 3B992, 3B993, and 3B994, with some exceptions.3 The item qualifies if it is a direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, was made in a plant or by major equipment that is, or contains an integrated circuit made in such a plant. That last condition is the tricky one. A note in the regulation says IC production includes wafer fabrication as well as assembly, testing, and packaging.3 A single control chip inside a tool can bring the whole tool into scope. On the end-user side, the rule covers Footnote 5 entities and entities at fabs in D:5 or Macau producing advanced-node logic or DRAM. The compliance date was December 31, 2024.15
Japan gets carve-outs here too. Supplement 4 to part 742 lists 33 countries excluded from certain semiconductor equipment license requirements, including Japan and the Netherlands.7 Under the SME FDP rule, the exclusion covers only items subject to the EAR under §734.4(a)(8) or §734.9(k) that are reexported or exported from abroad by an entity located in one of those countries, and only if neither the entity nor its ultimate parent company is headquartered in D:5 or Macau (742.4(a)(4)(ii)(B), with a parallel exclusion in 742.6(a)(6)(i)(A)(2)(ii)).7 Transfers (in-country) are not covered, and U.S.-origin items themselves are not items made subject to the EAR by those two provisions, so the exclusion does not reach them. Under the Footnote 5 rule, there is no license requirement when a company headquartered in one of those countries ships from Japan (744.11(a)(2)(v)).6 A note in the U.S. regulation itself records that Japan added advanced semiconductor equipment to its own control list on July 23, 2023.4
Does that make Japanese equipment makers safe? Not entirely. The exclusions depend on where the item ships from and where the company is headquartered, so the answer can change when a production site or sales subsidiary in Southeast Asia ships the tool, or when an overseas subsidiary transfers it within its country. The Footnote 1 and 4 rules have no Japan carve-out at all. And if the item is on Japan's control list, a FEFTA license is a separate requirement. Honestly, this is an area where it is easy to swing between "we're Japanese, so we're fine" and "stop everything." Building a small table of ship-from location against headquarters is usually the fastest way out.
The AI Diffusion Rule (January 2025) and where it stands now
On January 15, 2025, in the last days of the Biden Administration, the Framework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion (90 FR 4544) was published.16 It was the first rule to control AI model weights, creating ECCN 4E091 and the AI model weights FDP rule in paragraph (l). The same rule rewrote the advanced computing FDP rule's destination scope to worldwide.
On May 13, 2025, BIS announced it would rescind the rule. According to the release, the Under Secretary instructed enforcement officials not to enforce it, and BIS said it would publish a regulation formalizing the rescission and issue a replacement rule.20 The announcement came two days before the May 15 compliance date for most of the rule's requirements.
The rescission was formalized by the interim final rule effective November 19, 2026 (91 FR 74970). Its summary says the AI Diffusion Rule was never enforced and that the rule formalizes the rescission BIS announced in May 2025; it removed paragraph (l) and ECCN 4E091. Paragraph (h) of the advanced computing FDP rule was not amended, and its worldwide destination scope ((h)(2)(i)) was kept; the preamble gives the example of jurisdiction continuing after an item is incorporated into another foreign-made product such as a GPU board or server.1 The enforcement scope BIS had described in Federal Register preambles and guidance1718 is now reflected in the regulatory text. In practice, two points cover it:
- AI Diffusion Rule: rescission announced in May 2025 and formalized by the interim final rule of November 19, 2026 (91 FR 74970), which removed the country tiers, the model weights controls (4E091 and paragraph (l)), the Data Center VEU, and License Exceptions AIA and LPP
- Advanced computing FDP rule: (h) is still worldwide in the text. Licenses are required for the five countries in §742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A) (Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brazil and Thailand), for D:1, D:4 and D:5 (excluding A:5 and A:6) and the UAE (no license if only approved entities in Supplement No. 8 to Part 740 are the consignee and end users), and under §744.23 for entities headquartered in D:5 or Macau (from November 19, 2026)
The model-weights control was removed from the text on November 19, 2026. The chip controls behind AI are very much alive, with revised destinations.
Where Japanese suppliers get caught
These are the patterns that come up most in practice.
Pattern 1: Made in Japan, sold into a transaction involving a Footnote 1 or 4 entity
Japanese fabs typically run a mix of U.S., European, and Japanese tools. If any major equipment on the line is a direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, chips and wafers from that line can fall within FDPR's product scope. The regulation states that a foreign-produced item includes any wafer, finished or unfinished.3 If a Footnote 1 or 4 entity is involved as purchaser, consignee, or end user, a BIS license can be required even when the whole deal is domestic to Japan.
And these two rules ignore product classification. A general-purpose item that is "non-applicable" under Japan's classification and appears nowhere on the CCL can still be caught. "Made in a Japanese plant, by Japanese staff, sold in a Japan-domestic deal" and still needing a U.S. license: that is the realization that tends to stop people.
Pattern 2: Equipment makers shipping from overseas sites
As covered above, the SME and Footnote 5 rules carve out shipments from Japan by companies headquartered there. Once a tool ships from an overseas production site or sales subsidiary, the answer depends on the combination of ship-from country and headquarters country. Dual compliance with FEFTA and the EAR remains the baseline.
Customers sometimes ask suppliers for a certificate about FDPR status. Under 734.9(a)(2), BIS provides a model certificate in supplement 1 to part 734, in which a supplier states that an item would be subject to the EAR if future transactions meet an FDP rule's destination or end-user scope.3 It is not required by the EAR, and BIS itself says it is not the only due diligence step. Still, being able to explain your production equipment and ECCNs makes those conversations much shorter.
Pattern 3: Missing Russia diversion through third-country sites
The Russia/Belarus rules are broad, but shipments from Japan are excluded from their license requirements.8 What mainly binds shipments from Japan is FEFTA. The route that gets missed is a Japanese company's own site or distributor in Central Asia, the Middle East, or Southeast Asia reexporting to Russia: from countries not on supplement 3, the U.S. FDP rules apply in full. FDPR turns on knowledge, so the head office should require those sites to confirm their customers' ultimate destinations.
| Sector | Main risk |
|---|---|
| Logic and memory manufacturing | If line equipment meets the condition, Footnote 1 and 4 transactions are caught regardless of product classification |
| Equipment manufacturers | Carve-outs for shipments from Japan, but overseas sites and the origin of embedded ICs become the issue |
| Materials (photoresist, etc.) | Mostly de minimis, but FDPR needs a look if a Footnote 1 or 4 entity is involved |
| Components (HDD, SSD, etc.) | As the settlement shows, even general-purpose items raise FDPR questions in Footnote 1 transactions |
| Trading houses and logistics | Footnote status of customers, and Russia diversion through third-country sites |
Penalties and the published settlements
The consequences of an FDPR violation go well beyond what most teams expect.
- Civil penalty: up to $374,474 per violation (eCFR as of October 1, 2026; adjusted for inflation) or twice the transaction value, whichever is greater21
- Criminal: up to $1 million; individuals up to 20 years' imprisonment22
- Denial Order: a ban on dealing in items subject to the EAR, often the hardest operational blow
- Entity List designation of the company itself
- Multi-year audit obligations
The April 2023 settlement: $300 million
The best-known FDPR enforcement matter is a settlement BIS announced on April 19, 2023 with a major U.S. hard disk drive maker and its Singapore subsidiary.23 The following reflects BIS-published facts. (Listings and enforcement records are regulatory classifications and enforcement history, not a judgment of the companies involved.)
- Subject: the Huawei-related FDP rule (Footnote 1) as expanded on August 17, 2020
- Period: August 17, 2020 to September 29, 2021
- Volume: about 7.42 million drives worth about $1.1 billion
- Occasions: 429
- Civil penalty: $300 million, described by BIS as the largest standalone administrative penalty in its history
- Other terms: a multi-year audit requirement and a five-year suspended Denial Order
BIS explained that the drives were subject to the EAR because they were produced by an overseas plant or major component of a plant that was itself a direct product of U.S.-origin technology or software.23 That is the plant path this article keeps coming back to. The practical lesson is how far FDPR "knowledge" pushes supply-chain and destination diligence. Whether the situation was knowable matters more than intent, so even ordinary commercial deals need a way to trace production equipment and confirm final destinations.
Enforcement in 2025 and 2026
Enforcement has continued. On February 11, 2026, BIS announced a roughly $252 million settlement with a U.S. semiconductor equipment maker and its Korean subsidiary over tools shipped to Korea for assembly and then on to a company in China that had been on the Entity List since 2020.24 BIS said the penalty, twice the roughly $126 million transaction value, is the statutory maximum and the second-highest in its history. It was an export of U.S. equipment rather than an FDPR case, but it shows that assembling in a third country does not take an item outside U.S. controls.
On December 8, 2025, the Justice Department announced "Operation Gatekeeper," which it said disrupted a network that smuggled at least $160 million worth of U.S. AI chips to China and other restricted destinations; BIS's Office of Export Enforcement took part in the investigation.25 That too involved U.S.-made products rather than FDPR. More in our Operation Gatekeeper write-up.
Customer cutoffs and reputational damage add to the fine. My own view: the multi-year audit and the suspended denial order constrain a business for longer than the payment itself, and that is what weighs on the people doing the work.
Five practical steps
Step 1: Inventory your production equipment
List each tool's country of manufacture and whether it is a direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software. Because the test is about the technology rather than the country, you will need answers from your Japanese and European tool vendors. Cover lithography, etch, deposition, inspection, and other critical steps; under 734.9's definition, testing equipment counts as a major component.3
Step 2: Classify your products
Determine which ECCN, if any, applies to each product. EAR99 versus a specific ECCN such as 3A090 changes the answer under most rules. Just do not stop there: the Footnote 1 and 4 rules ignore product classification.
Step 3: Screen customers and end users
Check for Entity List status and Footnotes 1, 3, 4, and 5, for D:5- or Macau-headquartered entities, and for advanced-node fabs. For trading-house deals, push back to the ultimate destination. Mapping the parent and subsidiary relationships of key customers now will save time if the 50% rule comes back into force.
Step 4: Document transaction flows
Record which product, made on which equipment, went to whom. Keep vendor responses and customer certificates in the same file. If BIS investigates, this record is what shows how you reached your conclusions.
Step 5: Track rule changes continuously
FDPR has changed almost every year since 2020. In 2026, the November 19 rule removed paragraph (l) from 734.9 and rewrote the destinations for the advanced computing license requirement.1 BIS also uses guidance and Federal Register preambles to state its enforcement scope.1718 Watch the Federal Register, the eCFR, and BIS announcements, and update your export compliance program on a schedule.
Running all of this on spreadsheets gets hard quickly.
FAQ
Q1. Can a purely domestic deal in Japan trigger FDPR?
Yes. If the item meets a rule's product scope (for Footnotes 1 and 4, classification does not matter), the counterparty or final destination meets the rule's conditions, and the exporter knew or had reason to know, a U.S. license can be required even for a Japan-to-Japan sale.
Q2. Should we check de minimis or FDPR first?
Both. Run the de minimis calculation on controlled U.S.-origin content, and even if you fall under the threshold, run the FDPR production-origin check. FDPR is a yes-or-no test, so clearing de minimis does not clear FDPR.
Q3. Does using a single U.S.-made tool always trigger FDPR?
Country of manufacture does not decide it. The question is whether the product is a direct product of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, or was made in a plant or by major equipment that is. Many leading U.S. tools will meet that test, and a Japanese or European tool built from U.S.-origin technology can meet it too.
Q4. How does the Russia FDP rule affect Japanese companies?
Japan is listed in supplement 3 to part 746 with a full exclusion, so exports and reexports from Japan are outside the license requirements of the Russia/Belarus FDP rules. Japan's own FEFTA measures on Russia apply instead. Watch for routes through your own sites or distributors in countries that are not on supplement 3.
Q5. The AI Diffusion Rule was rescinded, so are AI-related exports fine now?
No. The AI Diffusion Rule was formally rescinded by the November 19, 2026 rule, but the worldwide scope of the advanced computing FDP rule has been kept. The November 19 rule (91 FR 74970) rewrote §742.6(a)(6)(iii)(A): a license is now required under (A)(1) for Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brazil and Thailand (consignees and end users headquartered in the U.S. are excluded if the §743.10 reporting is met) and under (A)(2) for D:1, D:4 and D:5 (excluding A:5 and A:6) and the UAE. For the UAE, no license is required when the ultimate consignee and all end users are approved UAE entities listed in Supplement No. 8 to Part 740 and specified as approved to receive these items. Entities headquartered in D:5 or Macau are caught by §744.23(a)(3)(i)(A).1
Q6. How do we decide whether our item is caught?
Work through it in order: the product's ECCN; the origin and ECCNs of the technology, software, and equipment used to make it; whether a counterparty carries a relevant Entity List footnote; whether the destination is covered; and whether a carve-out applies to where you ship from. When it is unclear, consider a CCATS classification request, a BIS advisory opinion, or outside counsel.
Q7. Will FDPR keep expanding?
The pattern so far: 2020 (Huawei), 2022 (Russia, advanced computing, supercomputers), 2023 (Iran, wider advanced computing scope), 2024 (Footnote 5, SME), 2025 (AI model weights, and the 50% affiliates language). In 2026, the November 19 rule removed paragraph (l) and kept the worldwide scope of paragraph (h). The next things to watch, in my view, are the 50% rule's stay deadline (January 10, 2027) and any changes after the comment deadline on the November 19 rule (January 19, 2027).
What changed since the first version
The table below lists what I rewrote after going back to the regulation and the newer Federal Register documents, compared with the first version (May 2026) and the July 2026 update.
| Item | Earlier version | As of October 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Advanced computing FDP destinations | 44 countries plus Macau | (h) worldwide in the text since January 2025, kept on November 19, 2026. Licenses required for five countries (Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brazil, Thailand), D:1, D:4, D:5 (excluding A:5 and A:6) and the UAE (no license if only Supplement No. 8 to Part 740 approved entities are the consignee and end users), and D:5- or Macau-headquartered entities (from November 19, 2026) |
| AI Diffusion Rule | Rescission announced in May 2025 | Formally rescinded by the interim final rule of November 19, 2026 (91 FR 74970); paragraph (l) and 4E091 removed |
| Footnote 3 | Military end users generally | Russian or Belarusian military end users and procurement entities (corrected) |
| Russia FDP and Japan | Japan-routed triangular trade could be caught | Shipments from Japan excluded (supplement 3 to part 746); third-country sites are the issue (corrected) |
| SME and Footnote 5 FDP and Japan | No mention of carve-outs | Carve-outs for shipments from Japan by Japan-headquartered companies (supplement 4 to part 742, 744.11); overseas sites depend on conditions (corrected) |
| 50% rule | Not covered | Affiliates language in the FDP rules stayed; extended through January 10, 2027 by a rule published November 9, 2026 (91 FR 70789) |
| Civil penalty cap | About $360,000 | $374,474 (eCFR as of October 1, 2026) |
| Operation Gatekeeper | A BIS enforcement initiative since 2024 | A Justice Department action announced in December 2025 against a U.S. AI chip smuggling network (corrected) |
| Advanced chip review policy | Not covered | January 2026: case-by-case review for H200-class and below to China and Macau (FDPR scope unchanged) |
Every correction came from re-reading the primary text. The Russia and semiconductor-equipment carve-outs in particular were errors that made the burden on Japanese suppliers look heavier than it is.
FDPR also intersects with Japan's own economic-security policy. At the Japan–India summit in Delhi on July 2, 2026, the two governments issued the Japan–India Joint Declaration on Economic Security Cooperation, committing to project-based cooperation in five priority areas: semiconductors, critical minerals, information and communications technology, clean energy and pharmaceuticals. The two leaders also welcomed that about ¥2 trillion of investment had already been decided toward the ¥10 trillion private investment target set in 2025 (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, "Japan-India Summit Meeting and Luncheon," July 2, 2026, in Japanese). At the joint press announcement, Prime Minister Takaichi said both countries regard strengthening supply chains for critical goods as an urgent task.26 As those supply chains, semiconductors and minerals included, get rebuilt among partners, tracking production origin, which is exactly what FDPR asks about, only gets more important. See also Japan–India summit and economic security.
Summary
- FDPR brings foreign-made items under the EAR when they are direct products of specified U.S.-origin technology or software, or were made in a plant or by major equipment that is
- De minimis looks at the share of controlled U.S. content; FDPR looks at where the tools and recipe came from
- The regulation has 10 rule types, (b) through (k); the families that matter most are Entity List, advanced computing, Russia/Belarus and semiconductor equipment (SME and Footnote 5). The AI model weights rule was removed on November 19, 2026
- Shipments from Japan get carve-outs under the Russia, SME, and Footnote 5 rules, but not under Footnotes 1 and 4 or advanced computing
- The AI Diffusion Rule was formally rescinded on November 19, 2026, removing (l) and 4E091; the 50% affiliates language is stayed (extended through January 10, 2027)
If I had to pick one task for this week, it would be asking the vendors of your critical process tools a single question: is this tool a direct product of U.S.-origin technology? Once those answers are in, it becomes clear which deals to pause and which you can keep running with confidence.
Related articles
- BIS 50% rule (Affiliates Rule): the stay deadline and the extension
- What an ECCN is and how to look one up
- EAR99 and how it counts in de minimis
- Operation Gatekeeper and the AI chip smuggling case
- Using Huawei Ascend chips and BIS's GP10 guidance
- The MATCH Act and U.S. semiconductor export controls
If you want counterparty screening, with the basis for each decision kept on file, to run as a routine process, you can contact us about TRAFEED (it does not determine FDPR status itself). An overview of its features is in the TRAFEED service catalog (PDF).
Related practical guides
References
Also consulted: BIS's page on 734.9 (https://www.bis.gov/regulations/ear/part-734/section-734.9/foreigndirect-product-fdp-rules ), the Commerce Department's August 2020 release on Huawei (https://www.commerce.gov/news/press-releases/2020/08/commerce-department-further-restricts-huawei-access-us-technology-and ), and JETRO's security trade control quick guide (January 2024, https://www.jetro.go.jp/ext_images/world/security_trade_control/pdf/guide/202401_v2.pdf ). [^fr70789]: Federal Register, "Extension of the Suspension of Expansion of End-User Controls for Affiliates of Certain Listed Entities" (91 FR 70789, published and effective November 9, 2026). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/11/09/2026-22793/extension-of-the-suspension-of-expansion-of-end-user-controls-for-affiliates-of-certain-listed
Footnotes
-
Federal Register, "Addressing Remote Access to Advanced Semiconductors" (91 FR 74970, published and effective November 19, 2026). Amendatory instruction 3b ("Amend Sec. 734.9 by removing paragraph (l)"), preamble IV.A (removal of ECCN 4E091), summary (formalizing the rescission of the AI Diffusion Rule), preamble D (paragraph (h)(2)(i) kept). Checked in the Federal Register text on November 20, 2026. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/11/19/2026-23529/addressing-remote-access-to-advanced-semiconductors ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 734.3 "Items subject to the EAR." https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-734/section-734.3 ↩
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 734.9 "Foreign-Direct Product (FDP) Rules" (text as of October 1, 2026, including the effective date note on the stayed 50% language in (e) and (g)). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-734/section-734.9 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 734.4 "De minimis U.S. content" (as of October 1, 2026). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-734/section-734.4 ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Federal Register, "Foreign-Direct Product Rules: Organization, Clarification, and Correction" (87 FR 6022, February 3, 2022). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/02/03/2022-02302/foreign-direct-product-rules-organization-clarification-and-correction ↩
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 744.11 (license requirements for Entity List entities, including Footnote 5). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-744/section-744.11 ↩ ↩2
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 742.4 "National security" and Supplement No. 4 to Part 742 "Countries Excluded From Certain Semiconductor Manufacturing Equipment License Requirements." https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-742 ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 746.8 "Sanctions against Russia and Belarus" and Supplement No. 3 to Part 746. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-746 ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Federal Register, "Implementation of Additional Export Controls: Certain Advanced Computing and Semiconductor Manufacturing Items..." (87 FR 62186, October 13, 2022). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2022/10/13/2022-21658/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-and-semiconductor ↩ ↩2
-
Federal Register, "Additions and Modifications to the Entity List; Removals From the Validated End-User (VEU) Program" (89 FR 96830, December 5, 2024). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/12/05/2024-28267/additions-and-modifications-to-the-entity-list-removals-from-the-validated-end-user-veu-program ↩ ↩2
-
Federal Register, "Expansion of End-User Controls To Cover Affiliates of Certain Listed Entities" (90 FR 47201, September 30, 2025). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/09/30/2025-19001/expansion-of-end-user-controls-to-cover-affiliates-of-certain-listed-entities ↩
-
Federal Register, "One Year Suspension of Expansion of End-User Controls for Affiliates of Certain Listed Entities" (90 FR 50857, November 12, 2025). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/11/12/2025-19846/one-year-suspension-of-expansion-of-end-user-controls-for-affiliates-of-certain-listed-entities ↩
-
Ministry of Commerce of the People's Republic of China, official briefing on the eighth round of China-U.S. economic and trade consultations (September 28, 2026, in Chinese). https://www.mofcom.gov.cn/syxwfb/art/2026/art_d9ea01824fc44fd8a29f7dc3f8ca9c72.html ↩
-
NBC News, report on the U.S.-China trade truce extension (September 23, 2026; press report). https://www.nbcnews.com/business/economy/us-china-extend-trade-truce-trump-rcna599525 ↩
-
Federal Register, "Implementation of Additional Export Controls: Certain Advanced Computing Items; Supercomputer and Semiconductor End Use..." (88 FR 73458, October 25, 2023). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/10/25/2023-23055/implementation-of-additional-export-controls-certain-advanced-computing-items-supercomputer-and ; Federal Register, "Foreign-Produced Direct Product Rule Additions, and Refinements to Controls for Advanced Computing and Semiconductor Manufacturing Items" (89 FR 96790, December 5, 2024). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/12/05/2024-28270/foreign-produced-direct-product-rule-additions-and-refinements-to-controls-for-advanced-computing ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Federal Register, "Framework for Artificial Intelligence Diffusion" (90 FR 4544, January 15, 2025). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2025/01/15/2025-00636/framework-for-artificial-intelligence-diffusion ↩ ↩2
-
Federal Register, "Enhanced Favorable Treatment for the United Arab Emirates Under the Export Administration Regulations" (91 FR 43034, July 14, 2026; the preamble states the enforcement scope for advanced computing items). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/07/14/2026-14132/enhanced-favorable-treatment-for-the-united-arab-emirates-under-the-export-administration ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
BIS, "Guidance Regarding Enforcement of License Requirements for Advanced Computing Items for Entities Headquartered in Country Group D:5 and Macau" (May 31, 2026). https://www.bis.gov/media/documents/bis-guidance-may-31-2026.pdf ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Federal Register, "Revision to License Review Policy for Advanced Computing Commodities" (91 FR 1684, January 15, 2026). https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/15/2026-00789/revision-to-license-review-policy-for-advanced-computing-commodities ↩
-
BIS, "Department of Commerce Announces Rescission of Biden-Era Artificial Intelligence Diffusion Rule, Strengthens Chip-Related Export Controls" (May 13, 2025). https://www.bis.gov/press-release/department-commerce-announces-rescission-biden-era-artificial-intelligence-diffusion-rule-strengthens ↩
-
eCFR, 15 CFR 6.3 "Adjustments for inflation to civil monetary penalties" (cap under 50 U.S.C. 4819, as of October 1, 2026). https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-A/part-6/section-6.3 ↩
-
50 U.S.C. 4819 "Penalties" (Export Control Reform Act of 2018). https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title50-section4819 ↩
-
BIS press release on the settlement with a hard disk drive maker (April 19, 2023). https://www.bis.gov/node/20250 ↩ ↩2
-
BIS press release on the settlement with a semiconductor equipment maker (February 11, 2026). https://media.bis.gov/sites/default/files/documents/AMAT%20to%20Pay%20%24252%20Million%20Penalty%20to%20BIS%20for%20Illegally%20Exporting%20Semiconductor%20Manufacturing%20Equipment.pdf ↩
-
U.S. Department of Justice, "U.S. Authorities Shut Down Major China-Linked AI Tech Smuggling Network" (December 8, 2025). https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/us-authorities-shut-down-major-china-linked-ai-tech-smuggling-network ↩
-
Prime Minister's Office of Japan, "Visit to India (2)" (joint press announcement, July 2, 2026, in Japanese). https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/105/actions/202607/02india2.html ↩






