Hello, this is Ryuta Hamamoto from TIMEWELL.
Picture an HR office at a Japanese university in the first week of April. Mixed in with the paperwork for new full-time faculty are employment contracts for part-time lecturers, an application to host a visiting researcher, papers to rehire a retiring professor as a specially appointed professor, an agreement for a researcher seconded from a company, and a cross-appointment agreement with a university overseas. Which of these people should sign the export control pledge (the specific-category pledge), when, and how? If you start from job titles, you never get an answer.
The job title is not what decides it. Two questions do: is the person under the university's direction (an employment relationship, or something equivalent), and are they a resident? Sort the types of appointment by those two questions and most of the confusion goes away. Below is that table, the situations where you need a new pledge, and how to keep the HR ledger, all following the original text of METI's Notice on Services, its Q&A and the fifth-edition guidance for universities.
The short version
- Anyone the university employs is under its direction, whether full-time or part-time, on a fixed term or not, postdoc or not. Take a pledge when they start and receive later changes through reporting. For part-time lecturers and others not covered by the side-job rules, write the reporting promise into the pledge itself.
- Visiting researchers and professors emeriti the university does not employ are not under its direction. Check them against the documents you normally collect when hosting them. Category 3 (people acting on a foreign government's instructions or requests) is checked only by whether documents make it clear, employed or not.
- The test for a new pledge is whether employment ended once and started again. Take a new one when you receive a secondee or rehire after retirement; do not when a contract renews without a gap. A cross-appointment with a foreign institution calls for a Category 1 review and a check on whether there is a priority agreement.
This article is not about anyone's nationality or origin. The specific categories are procedural classifications that can apply to Japanese faculty too, regardless of nationality (guidance p. 41; Deemed Export Q&A Q3). METI itself writes that falling under a specific category does not mean someone is regarded as a security concern1. For the timeline from job posting to departure, see what HR checks when hiring foreign faculty and researchers; for the details of pledge forms, seals and refusals, see our explainer on pledges (in Japanese). Here I focus on the differences between types of appointment.
Two questions decide the method: under direction, and resident
Start with residency. The specific categories apply to "residents who are natural persons," so if you give controlled technology to a non-resident, you check whether a license is needed for provision to a non-resident, pledge or no pledge2. Residency depends on where someone lives and works, not on nationality. The fifth-edition guidance says foreign nationals who work at an office in Japan, or who have been in Japan for six months or more since entry, are residents (p. 39). A foreign national employed by a Japanese university for only two months is also a resident if they live in Japan during those two months and the university salary is their main source of income. The same note says that someone who is employed but works without having entered Japan and without a residence in Japan (remote work and so on) is a non-resident (p. 39, note 36)3.
If the person is a resident, next ask whether they are under the university's direction. Annex 1-3 of the Notice on Services (the guideline for judging whether someone falls under a specific category) splits the method for Categories 1 and 2 in two2. For people under the provider's direction, you have exercised the ordinary duty of care if you confirm by self-declaration at the point they come under your direction (you can use the sample pledge in Annex 1-4) and require them to report if they newly fall under Category 1 or 2 later. For people not under your direction, you look at whether the contracts or similar documents you would normally obtain in the course of business before the transaction make it clear that they fall under Category 1 or 2. If those documents do not make it clear, no further check is required.
"Under direction" here means an employment relationship or one equivalent to it. An equivalent relationship is one where the person provides labor under a contract other than an employment contract but, given how the work is actually done, would count as a worker under the Labor Standards Act (guidance footnote 40 on p. 45; Deemed Export Q&A Q17)34. The guidance asks universities to treat professors, lecturers and others employed by the university as under the university's direction "whether full-time or part-time," and students the university does not employ as not under its direction (p. 45). Page 51 says the same thing: ask employees (faculty and staff) for self-declarations such as pledges, and check non-employees (students and so on) against documents normally obtained, such as admission papers3. The model rules in the guidance define faculty and staff as "professors, associate professors, lecturers and other employees employed by the university," full-time or part-time (p. 107, Article 2(17)).
Category 3 (people who receive instructions or requests from a foreign government regarding their conduct in Japan) is handled quite differently. Annex 1-3 says that for Category 3, whether or not the person is under the provider's direction, you fail the duty of care "only" when the contracts or similar documents make it clear that the person falls under Category 3 and you carelessly provide the technology anyway2. So even for a full-time professor, Category 3 is not something the pledge checks. The sample pledge in Annex 1-4 covers only items 1 and 2 of section 1(3)(sa) of the Notice. The Deemed Export Q&A (Q34) explains that Category 3 is not normally expected to be checked by self-declaration4. HR does not need to question anyone about Category 3.
One thing applies across the board: a notice from METI. For Categories 1, 2 and 3 alike, if METI tells you a person may fall under a category and you carelessly provide technology anyway, you have not exercised the duty of care (Annex 1-3). Put together:
| Person | How to check Categories 1 and 2 | How to check Category 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Under the university's direction (employment or an equivalent relationship) | Self-declaration (pledge) when they come under direction; require reports if they newly fall under a category | Whether contracts or similar documents make it clear; no further check required if not |
| Not under the university's direction | Whether contracts or similar documents make it clear; no further check required if not | Same |
| Both | If METI tells you someone may fall under a category, do not carelessly provide technology | Same |
Seen this way, what HR has to decide comes down to one point: is this person under the university's direction? Two people both called "visiting professor" can land in different rows depending on whether there is an employment contract. Full-time versus part-time, fixed-term or not, postdoc or not: none of these changes the row.
The table, by type of appointment
The table below applies those two questions to the types of appointment a university HR office handles. The basis column gives where the original text says it; where the original does not answer directly and I have applied its criteria, I mark it "our reading." Category 3 is checked the same way in every row (whether documents make it clear), so it is left out. Your university's export control officer makes the final call.
| Type of appointment | Resident? (rule of thumb) | Under the university's direction? | How and when to check Categories 1 and 2 | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full-time professors, associate professors, lecturers, assistant professors (including fixed-term) | Resident if employed and living in Japan | Yes | Pledge on starting, at the latest before any controlled technology is provided; later changes through side-job declarations and other reports | Annex 1-3 1(2), Q21, Q23, guidance p. 45 |
| Part-time lecturers employed by the university | Same | Yes (full-time or part-time makes no difference) | Pledge; if the side-job rules do not apply to them, add "I will report if I newly fall under a category" | Guidance p. 45, footnote 42 on p. 46, Q26 |
| Part-time lecturers who live abroad and teach online | Non-resident if they have no residence in Japan | There is an employment relationship | Not the specific-category pledge; if controlled technology is provided, check whether a license is needed for provision to a non-resident | Guidance p. 39, note 36 (application is our reading) |
| Postdocs and specially appointed researchers employed by the university | Resident even on a short contract, if living in Japan and the salary is the main income | Yes | Pledge, whatever the form of employment | Q21, Q&A for universities Q16, guidance p. 39, note 36 |
| Researchers with no employment contract (hosted on outside funding and so on) | May be non-residents, for example within six months of entry | No (yes, if the actual work makes them a worker) | Whether the documents normally collected when hosting them (application, CV, hosting papers) make it clear | Annex 1-3 1(1), guidance footnote 40 on p. 45 and p. 51 (application is our reading) |
| Visiting researchers and visiting professors not employed | Same; if technology goes to the overseas institution where they hold a post, judge by that institution | No | Whether hosting documents make it clear; a sabbatical professor holding a post at a foreign university who has become a resident is Category 1, employed or not | Q64, Q&A for universities Q20, case collection p. 4 |
| Visiting professors employed part-time and paid | Resident if living in Japan | Yes | Pledge | Guidance p. 45 (that employment, not the title, decides is our reading) |
| The university's own professors emeriti (title only, no employment or commission) | Depends on residence | No | If technology will be provided, for example through continued lab use, whether the hosting documents make it clear | School Education Act Article 106, Annex 1-3 1(1) (application is our reading) |
| Professors emeriti rehired as specially appointed professors | Resident if living in Japan | Newly under direction | New pledge at rehiring; not needed for later renewals | Q28 |
| Cross-appointment with a Japanese university, national lab or company | Resident if living in Japan | Yes (employment contracts with both institutions) | Pledge if they are new to the university; a Japanese counterpart alone does not create Category 1 | Notice 1(3)(sa)1, Q45, supplement p. 3 |
| Cross-appointment with a foreign university or institution | Resident if living in Japan | Yes | Normally a Category 1 candidate; exception if there is an agreement that the university's direction takes priority | METI explanatory material p. 3, Q43, Q44, Q46, Q47 |
| Secondees from companies and others (the university is the host; in-place or transfer secondment) | Resident if living in Japan | Yes, under the host university | The university takes the pledge, including when the sending organization is in the same group | Q27 |
| Graduate students employed as RAs or TAs | Depends on residence (for international students, time since entry and so on) | Yes, to the extent of the employment | Pledge | Our reading of the reverse of the guidance's p. 45 sentence; case collection p. 61 (University I) |
| Agency workers from a staffing agency | Depends on residence | Not employed by the university | Normally neither the university nor the agency needs to check, except in cases such as the agency having the worker receive technology to get around the rules, or the contract naming the worker as the recipient | Q15 |
Look down the table and the rows split cleanly by whether there is an employment contract. The top half, people the university employs, gets the same treatment whatever the title: a pledge on starting, then changes through reporting. The bottom half, people it does not employ, is checked against hosting documents. The exceptions are people employed while living abroad (they are non-residents, so the pledge has no role) and agency workers (as Q15 explains, the technology is treated as passing from the host to the agency and then to the worker, and except in special cases, the agency's provision to the worker is not normally a "transaction").
My recommendation is to start HR's procedure with one line: "Everyone who signs an employment contract with the university submits a pledge on starting, without exception." The Deemed Export Q&A (Q22) does say you need not check people who are never expected to receive controlled technology, but it adds that if such a person turns out to fall under a specific category and technology is provided, the provider is not excused4. Footnote 48 on p. 51 of the guidance likewise allows universities to exclude administrative staff and students with no connection to technology transactions, with the same warning3. Part-time lecturers and postdocs are exactly the people whose likelihood of touching lab technology changes mid-year. Rather than having HR judge each person's prospects, put the pledge into the employment paperwork from the start. Nothing slips through, and the procedure never splits by nationality. The pledge items and a schedule worked back from the start date are in the hiring flow and declaration item list (Word, in Japanese). The items work as they are for any type of appointment, regardless of nationality.
Replace siloed classification work with AI.
METI's FY2024 data shows 52% of foreign exchange law violations stem from classification errors. Download the TRAFEED product catalog covering features and rollout.
Five types of appointment where people get stuck
Of the rows in the table, the ones HR actually gets asked about are part-time lecturers, postdocs, visitors, professors emeriti and cross-appointments. For none of them does the original text answer by name very often. So I take the original criteria (employment or not, resident or not, a contract with a foreign institution or not) and apply them one at a time.
Part-time lecturers: if you employ them, they are treated like full-time staff, and the reporting promise goes in the pledge
If the university employs a part-time lecturer, the method is the same as for full-time faculty, because the guidance says they are under the university's direction "whether full-time or part-time" (p. 45)3. The Deemed Export Q&A (Q21) also says that not only regular employees but part-timers, casual workers and technical intern trainees, whatever the form of employment, give a pledge at the point they come under the employer's direction4.
The difference shows up afterwards, in reporting. For full-time faculty, if the rules of employment require declaring side jobs and conflicts of interest, those rules count as requiring a report when someone newly falls under Category 1 or 2 (Annex 1-3). Part-time lecturers, however, are sometimes not covered by those rules. Footnote 42 on p. 46 of the guidance says that where there are such rules "but some faculty and staff, such as part-time staff, are not covered by them," asking those people for a self-declaration through a pledge or similar, and including a request that they "report if they newly fall under a specific category in the future," is considered to be in line with the guideline3. The same footnote also says that HR simply receiving declarations is not enough; the information has to be used by the export control office to keep track of who falls under a category.
METI's case collection (August 2023) shows universities running exactly this split5. University A checks current full-time staff through side-job notifications and part-time staff through pledges (p. 10). University G takes pledges from current part-time staff who have no duty to submit side-job notifications or conflict-of-interest declarations, while part-time staff who do have that duty are checked by the central office in the same way as full-time staff (p. 46). University I takes pledges (declarations) from part-time lecturers, TAs, RAs and others and records them in a ledger of people falling under specific categories (p. 61).
If your university brings in part-time lecturers on a commission or service contract rather than an employment contract, what counts is how the work is actually done, not the name of the contract. If the actual work makes them a worker under the Labor Standards Act, that is an "equivalent relationship" under direction (footnote 40 on p. 45). Judging worker status is HR's own field, but if you are unsure, taking a pledge is the safer choice (our suggestion). A part-time lecturer who lives abroad and teaches online is a non-resident if they have no residence in Japan (p. 39, note 36). In that case what you check is not a pledge but the content of the technology provided through classes and materials. Whether a lecture using a published textbook, or an online course, can use the exemptions that need no license is a question the guidance lists among its sample questions from universities, pointing to pp. 61 and 62 (p. 102). Ask your research promotion or export control office to check it.
Postdocs and specially appointed researchers: employed, or hosted?
If the university employs postdocs or specially appointed researchers, they sign a pledge just like full-time faculty, however short the contract. Q16 of the Q&A for universities (February 2021) says a foreign national employed by a Japanese university for only two months is a resident from the time of employment6. Note 36 of the fifth edition gives the conditions: they live in Japan during those two months, and the university salary is their main source of income (p. 39)3. As for timing, Q23 says from the start date and at the latest before any controlled technology is provided. You can check earlier, at the offer stage, but only with the person's voluntary cooperation, and you still need to take a pledge again after hiring (Q24)4.
The tricky case is a researcher hosted without an employment contract, for example someone who comes with funding from an outside body and is hosted as a "researcher" without being employed. With no employment relationship, and no worker status in practice, they are not under the university's direction, and you check them against the documents normally collected when hosting (our reading, based on the criteria in Q17 and Q18). The title may say "researcher," but the row is the same as a visiting researcher's. A field on the hosting application asking "Will the person sign an employment contract with the university?" settles which row applies at the door (our suggestion).
Visiting researchers and visiting professors: the contract decides, not the title
What "visiting" means differs from university to university. A visiting professor employed part-time and paid is under the university's direction. A visiting researcher who is given a place to do research but not employed is not. METI's case collection, in its table of common checking patterns, lists "students, invited faculty and so on" as examples of people not under direction (p. 4)5. In the same collection, University E classifies visiting faculty as not under direction, and the host faculty member checks for specific categories from what is written in the hosting paperwork (p. 33).
Even for visitors you do not employ, two situations need care. The first is a professor who arrives while keeping a post at a foreign university. The Deemed Export Q&A (Q64), on professors from foreign universities hosted under a sabbatical scheme, says that if they are non-residents, for example because they have no employment contract with the Japanese university and fewer than six months have passed since entry, they have always been subject to deemed-export control. It goes on to say that once they have become residents, they fall under Category 1 whether or not they have an employment relationship with the Japanese university4. The second is who receives the technology. Q20 of the Q&A for universities says that for a researcher who came to Japan while keeping a post at an overseas university or similar, if you provide technology to the researcher personally you judge by the researcher's residency, and if you provide it to the institution where they hold the post you judge by the institution's residency6.
For what to look for in the hosting documents, the simple YES/NO chart on p. 148 of the guidance helps. Its first question for Category 1 is whether the person has an "employment contract (whatever it is called, one that binds them in time and place)" with a foreign university, company or government, or a director's or auditor's mandate3. Hosting applications for visitors normally already ask for affiliation and position. If that field makes it possible to read whether the person is employed by, or holds a post at, a foreign institution, you can answer Annex 1-3's question of whether documents make it clear (our suggestion).
Professors emeriti: conferring a title is not employment
Article 106 of the School Education Act says that a university "may confer the title of professor emeritus," in accordance with its own rules, on a person who served there as president, vice president, dean, professor, associate professor or lecturer and made particularly distinguished contributions to education or scholarship7. What the article provides for is the conferral of a title, not employment. A professor emeritus who holds only the title, with no employment or commission, is naturally treated as not under the university's direction (our reading).
If a professor emeritus will receive technology after retiring, for example by continuing to use a lab, joining joint research or attending closed seminars, check against the hosting documents for that arrangement (an application to use the lab and so on). If no provision of technology is expected at all, you can leave them out of the check under the approach in Q22, but as noted above, you are not excused if technology is actually provided. Rehiring a professor emeritus as a specially appointed professor changes things. A new employment relationship begins, so, as Q28 in the next section says, take a new pledge at the time of rehiring.
The question also comes from the other direction: a faculty member has received an honorary professorship from a foreign university. The Deemed Export Q&A (Q63) says there is no need to treat them as Category 2 merely because they received the title of professor emeritus. Decorations and other things that are hard to value in money likewise need not be treated as Category 2 merely because they were received, except in special cases such as one made of extremely valuable material4. Category 1 requires a contract with a foreign institution, such as employment, and direction or a duty of care based on it (Notice 1(3)(sa)1). If the title comes with a teaching or research contract, it becomes a question of holding a professorship at a foreign university concurrently, under Q46. How to list an emeritus title on research grant applications is a separate procedure, covered in Q5 of our Q&A on disclosing foreign funding, side jobs and cross-appointments.
Cross-appointments: is the other institution foreign?
A cross-appointment lets a researcher work for several institutions under a separate employment contract with each. The "Basic Framework and Points to Note for the Cross-Appointment System [Supplement]" by METI and MEXT (2020) assumes the in-place secondment form, in which the worker signs employment contracts with two or more institutions under an arrangement (an agreement or similar) between the sending and receiving institutions (p. 3)8. In its section on safety and health, it says both the sending and the receiving institution give the worker specific direction (p. 21). From the university's side, a cross-appointed researcher is under its direction through their employment contract with it. If they are new to the university, take a pledge when they start.
Whether they fall under a specific category depends on the other institution. Category 1 requires a contract with a legal entity established under foreign law, a foreign government or similar (Notice 1(3)(sa)1)2. If the other side is a Japanese university, national lab or company, that relationship alone does not create Category 1. Someone employed by a Japanese subsidiary of a foreign company does not fall under it either. However, if that Japanese company is an SPC with no real business that can effectively be equated with a foreign entity, Category 1 may apply (Q45). A foreign university or institution is another matter. METI's explanatory material, "On clarifying the operation of deemed-export control," lists "faculty and staff of Japanese universities who hold side jobs (including cross-appointments) at foreign universities" as an example of Category 1 expected at universities and research institutions (p. 3)1. Q46 says a professor who also holds a professorship at a foreign university normally falls under Category 1 unless the exception in item (i) or (ii) of Category 1 applies. Q47 says that even if the employer has approved the side job, a license application is still needed as long as the person falls under a specific category4.
The exception is an agreement that the university's direction takes priority. Item (i) of Category 1 in the Notice excludes cases where the person has an employment or similar contract with a Japanese entity and works under its direction (or owes it a duty of care), and the Japanese entity or the person has agreed with the foreign entity or foreign government that the Japanese entity's direction or duty of care takes priority over the foreign side's. Q43 says that with such an agreement the person does not fall under Category 1. Q44 says the agreement need not necessarily be in writing, but if the other side is not a "group foreign entity," METI may ask for documents showing that the agreement exists and what it says4. The group exception in item (ii) does not normally apply to university corporations, which have no group companies linked by capital (guidance footnote 39 on p. 43)3. Writing which institution's direction takes priority into the cross-appointment agreement with a foreign institution is the surest way to be able to show it later (our suggestion).
One thing caught my eye. The main text of the supplement never mentions the Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act, export control or national security (our search). Yet its Table 2, contrasting cross-appointments with side jobs, says that depending on the agreement, a cross-appointee may use both organizations' research facilities and access their sensitive information (p. 11). The sample list of items to coordinate within the university, at the end, includes fields for the other institution's country (for overseas institutions) and its parent company8. Universities need to add a step to their internal procedure that sends the case to the export control office as soon as HR begins coordinating the agreement. In the case collection, University C asks current staff who submit an application for a side job or cross-appointment to submit a pledge each time, through their direct supervisor (p. 21)5. How to list a cross-appointment on research grant applications is in Q3 of the Q&A on disclosure mentioned above. For deciding which procedure foreign funding, side jobs and concurrent posts should be declared under, you can also use the declarant worksheet and internal declaration form in the disclosure decision flow for foreign funding, side jobs and concurrent posts (Excel, in Japanese).
Falling under Category 1 does not mean dropping the hire or the agreement. Q59 says METI does not intend to refuse licenses across the board just because someone falls under a specific category. Q8 does not rule out having the person keep working while access to the technology is restricted during the license application or after a refusal. No report to METI is needed either (Q9)4.
When to take a new pledge: secondment, rehiring, renewed terms
A pledge is taken at the "point" someone comes under the university's direction. So whether to take a new one depends on whether they have newly come under direction. The Deemed Export Q&A (Q28) says that when employment ends once, for example when an employee retires at the mandatory age and signs a new employment contract, and a new employment relationship begins with rehiring, the person newly comes under direction and a new pledge is needed. When employment continues, as with renewing a rehiring contract, a new pledge is not needed4. On secondees, Q27 says that in both in-place and transfer secondments the secondee normally has an employment relationship with the host and is under the host's direction, so the host takes the pledge. The same applies when the host and the sending organization are in the same capital group.
Applying those two answers to situations common at universities gives the following. I have separated the rows the Q&A answers directly from the rows where I have applied its reasoning.
| Situation | Newly under direction? | Pledge | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Receiving a secondee from a company or another university (in-place or transfer) | Yes (the university is the host) | The university takes one | Q27 |
| Rehiring after mandatory retirement as a specially appointed professor or similar | Yes (employment ends once) | New pledge | Q28 |
| Renewing a rehiring contract | No (employment continues) | Not needed | Q28 |
| Renewing a fixed-term faculty contract with no gap | No | Not needed | Our reading (Q28's reasoning) |
| A fixed term ends and the person is hired again after a gap | Yes | New pledge | Our reading (Q28's reasoning) |
| Sending the university's own faculty on in-place secondment elsewhere | Employment with the university continues; the host takes the pledge | No new pledge appears to be needed at the university; collect changes during the secondment through reporting when they return | Q27 (the university's side is our reading) |
| Moving from part-time to full-time, or from postdoc to assistant professor, at the same university | Yes if done as resignation and new hire; no if employment continues through the switch | Decide by the form of the procedure; review the reporting basis (rules of employment or the pledge) if it changes | Our reading (Q28's reasoning; footnote 42 on p. 46) |
| Starting a cross-appointment with a foreign institution | Not at the university | The requirement is reporting; University C takes a pledge each time | Annex 1-3 1(2)(a), case collection p. 21 |
| Already employed on 1 May 2022 | Already under direction then | Requiring a report if they newly fall under a category is enough | Annex 1-3 1(2)(a), Q1, Q2 |
The confusing case is part-time lecturers who sign a new contract every term or every year. Q28's test is whether "employment ends once and starts anew," so if there is a gap between contracts and employment lapses each time, the natural reading is that the person newly comes under direction. If renewals follow on without a break, no new pledge is needed. If the contract form makes it hard to tell, retaking the pledge costs the lecturer and HR very little, so it is safer to retake it whenever in doubt (our suggestion).
When someone switches type of appointment, also check the reporting arrangement. Moving to full-time brings them under the side-job rules, so the rules of employment can carry the reporting. Moving the other way, from full-time to part-time or to a rehiring contract, can take them out of those rules. In that case, as footnote 42 on p. 46 says, make up for it by writing the reporting promise into the pledge. For people employed before 1 May 2022, Q2 says that if the rules of employment prohibit side jobs and conflicts of interest or require them to be declared, the reporting duty counts as imposed, but adds that this assumes the employer actually knows their current side jobs; if it does not, it needs to check again4.
Even when no new pledge is needed, you still need a channel for receiving changes. Page 81 of the guidance says that when a person you have taken in reports something relevant to specific categories, for example through side-job reporting, or METI contacts you about them, the security export control checks have to be done again3. How to set up the route from side-job and secondment notices received by HR to the export control office, with draft wording, is in the section "Getting HR declarations to the export control office" of our gap check of university export control rules.
How to keep the HR ledger
Once you have settled how each type of appointment is handled, record it in an HR ledger. The point of the ledger is that anyone can later trace "how and when this person was checked" and "whether something has happened that calls for a new pledge." Page 51 of the guidance recommends that the office responsible for taking people in and the export control office work together to check for specific categories at admission and hiring, and that information on people who fall under a category be gathered in the export control office3. The HR ledger is the record at that entrance.
I suggest the following columns. This is our suggestion; the guidance does not prescribe columns.
| Column | What to write | Mainly written by |
|---|---|---|
| Reference number | Keep names separately; use a number here | HR |
| Type of appointment and contract | Employment contract, commission, title only, secondment agreement, cross-appointment agreement and so on | HR |
| Under direction? | Yes or no, and the basis (there is an employment contract, and so on) | HR writes it; export control confirms |
| Contract start and end, and any gap | Used to decide on new pledges | HR |
| Residency check | Whether they have a residence in Japan; date of entry (for the six-month rule of thumb) | HR |
| How and when Categories 1 and 2 were checked | Date the pledge was taken and the form's version, or the type and date of the hosting documents checked | HR |
| Basis for reporting | Whether the side-job rules apply, or the reporting promise in the pledge | HR |
| Trigger for a new pledge | Secondment, rehiring, end of term and new hire, start of a cross-appointment with a foreign institution and so on | HR |
| Date passed to export control and result | Not applicable, needs checking, license application or narrowing the technology provided | Export control |
| Retention deadline | Decided as described below | Export control |
There is no nationality column, because neither the specific categories nor residency are determined by nationality. HR does handle nationality-related information for other legal purposes, such as the foreign worker employment notification, but keep those records apart from this ledger (see "Keep HR's nationality-related information apart from the export control check" in our article on the hiring flow). Do not use what is in the pledge or the ledger's results for decisions on hiring, evaluation or treatment, and limit who can see the ledger to the people who need to. In the case collection, University G lets the central export control desk and the HR division see every department's list, and each department's administrative office see only its own (p. 46). University E has HR check for specific categories through pledges and share the results with the export control office, and is considering managing the information in its HR database so it stays current (p. 33)5.
Think about retention in two parts. For the pledge itself, the Deemed Export Q&A (Q36) says it is desirable to keep it for the period during which technology is expected to be provided to the person, for example while they are employed. If technology was provided to someone who falls under a specific category, it says it is desirable to keep the records on their category status, including the self-declaration, as part of the documents on export and related business: five years for technology related to conventional weapons and seven years for technology related to weapons of mass destruction4. Footnote 41 on p. 45 of the guidance likewise says it is desirable to keep the records, whether or not the person falls under a category, for the period during which technology is expected to be provided, and to keep them as documents on the technology provision if technology was provided3. Paper pledges can be scanned to PDF and kept, and pledges can also be collected through Microsoft Forms or Google Forms (Q35). A seal or signature is not required if there is other evidence that the person confirmed the pledge (Q33).
If you collect information for these checks from candidates before hiring (at the job posting, selection or offer stage), the Employment Security Act comes in. Article 5-5 requires those recruiting workers and others to collect job seekers' personal information within the scope needed to achieve the purpose of their business, making the purpose clear, and to keep and use it within the scope of that purpose (except with the person's consent or for other legitimate reasons)9. The guidelines under the Act (Ministry of Labour Notice No. 141 of 1999) say that "race, ethnicity, social status, family origin, registered domicile, place of birth and other matters that may cause social discrimination," beliefs and creed, and labor union membership must not be collected, and then add that this does not apply "where there is a special occupational need or it is otherwise indispensable for achieving the purpose of the business, and the information is collected from the person after showing the purpose of collection"10. The pledge is basically taken after the person starts (Q23), and checking earlier at the offer stage depends on the person's voluntary cooperation (Q24). If you do collect information earlier, collect it from the person after showing the purpose (managing technology provision under the Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act) and scope, and confirm the approach with your university's legal and labor affairs staff.
If you do not have time to build the columns from scratch, the "people ledger" sheet in the 90-day plan and ledger set for a two-person team (Excel, in Japanese) works. It has fields for the category (employed faculty and staff, TAs and RAs, or non-employed students, research students and invited faculty), date of entry with the six-month date calculated automatically, Categories 1 to 3, the date the pledge was taken and its version, the type of document checked when checking by document, and declarations of side jobs and contracts with foreign institutions. It has no nationality column. Add the two columns "contract start and end" and "trigger for a new pledge" from the table above, and you can run it in the same shape as this article's table.
Wrapping up: three things to settle before April
Universities call their appointments by different names, and new forms appear almost every year. The questions that decide the method do not change: is the person under the university's direction, are they a resident, and do they have a contract with a foreign institution?
Before the April pile of contracts arrives, here are the three things I would have the HR office settle. First, for everyone who signs an employment contract, put the pledge into the onboarding paperwork, whatever the type of appointment. Second, for people not covered by the side-job rules, write the reporting promise into the pledge. Third, make sure the hosting documents for visitors and emeriti you do not employ show whether they are employed by, or hold a post at, a foreign institution, and write the priority of direction into cross-appointment agreements.
Personally, I think the healthiest outcome is for the "our reading" entries in the basis column to shrink over time. For any row where you hesitated, talk it through once with your export control office and write the answer in the ledger's notes column. By the following April, those notes will have become the HR office's procedure manual.
What we could not confirm, and what to read next
As of 22 November 2026, when this article was written, the following were not confirmed.
- I could not obtain, and have not checked, the main text of the 2014 "Basic Framework and Points to Note for the Cross-Appointment System" or METI's FAQ on cross-appointments. This article relies only on the 2020 supplement (as posted by MEXT).
- METI's Q&A and guidance do not answer by name for the university's own professors emeriti (title only), researchers hosted without employment, RAs and TAs, part-time lecturers on term-by-term contracts, or sending the university's own faculty out on in-place secondment. Rows marked "our reading" apply the original criteria.
- Whether part-time lecturers engaged on commission or service contracts count as workers under the Labor Standards Act depends on each contract and how the work is done; this article does not decide it.
- The Q&A for universities (February 2021) predates the specific-category approach (in force from 1 May 2022). Its answers on residency (Q16, Q17, Q20) still apply, but for the specific categories I checked the Notice on Services and the fifth edition.
- This article cannot decide whether particular technology is controlled or whether a particular person falls under a specific category. Your university's export control officer makes the final decision; for cases in doubt, ask METI's consultation desk.
What to read next:
- What HR checks when hiring foreign faculty and researchers: the timeline from job posting to departure, notices to candidates, and model wording for the rules of employment and contracts
- Pledges in METI's Q&A (in Japanese): editing the form, seals, retention, refusals (Q16 to Q38)
- Specific categories and license applications in METI's Q&A (in Japanese): examples of Categories 1 to 3, and the answers on emeriti and sabbaticals (Q39 to Q65)
- The Q&A for universities: residents, non-residents and violations (in Japanese): residence-based judgment, six months, researchers keeping overseas posts
- Filling in university pre-check sheets and review sheets: what the person fills in before being taken in, and what the export control office fills in
- Gap check of university export control rules: the article on pledges and resubmission, and getting HR declarations to the export control office
- Q&A on disclosing foreign funding, side jobs and cross-appointments: disclosure on the research grant and questionnaire side
If you want to keep faculty and staff check records and re-pledge triggers in a people ledger linked to your case ledger, talk to the TRAFEED team. You can contact us here.
Sources
Footnotes
-
METI Trade Control Department, Security Export Control Division, "On Clarifying the Operation of Deemed-Export Control" (in Japanese), p. 3, "Examples of people expected to fall under specific categories at universities and research institutions." It states that the specific categories are a typology of cases that need individual review, and that falling under a category does not mean a person is regarded as a security concern. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/law_document/minashi/meikakukanitsuite2.pdf (checked on 22 November 2026 against our copy of the original obtained on 21 November 2026) ↩ ↩2
-
METI, notice on transactions or acts providing technology that require a license under Article 25(1) of the Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act and Article 17(2) to (4) of the Foreign Exchange Order (the Notice on Services, 4 Bōkyoku No. 492) (in Japanese). Last amended by Export Notice 2025 No. 27 (promulgated 14 November 2025, in force 14 February 2026). Section 1(3)(sa) (definition of specific categories), Annex 1-3 (guideline for judging specific categories), Annex 1-4 (sample pledge). https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/law_document/tutatu/t10kaisei/ekimu_tutatu.pdf (checked against our copy of the original on 22 November 2026) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
METI, "Guidance on Sensitive Technology Management for Security Trade Control (for Universities and Research Institutions), Fifth Edition" (in Japanese), September 2025. Passages used: residency (p. 39 and note 36), specific categories (pp. 41 to 43 and footnote 39), the purpose of the guideline for judging specific categories (pp. 44 to 46 and footnotes 40 to 42), checking and central tracking (p. 51 and footnote 48), reports during enrollment and employment (p. 81), sample questions from universities (p. 102), Article 2(17) of the model rules (p. 107), simple YES/NO chart (p. 148). https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/daigaku/guidance5.pdf (checked against our copy of the original on 22 November 2026) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12
-
METI, "Q&A on Clarifying Deemed-Export Control" (in Japanese), revised 8 August 2023. Q1 to Q3, Q8, Q9, Q15, Q17, Q18, Q21 to Q24, Q26 to Q28, Q33 to Q36, Q43 to Q47, Q59, Q63, Q64. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/law_document/minashi/minashiqa3.pdf (checked against our copy of the original on 22 November 2026) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13
-
METI, "Case Collection on Security Export Control at Universities and Research Institutions [Responding to the Clarification of Deemed-Export Control]" (in Japanese), August 2023. Page numbers are the printed ones: patterns of checking methods (p. 4), Case 1, University A (p. 10), Case 3, University C (p. 21), Case 5, University E (p. 33), Case 7, University G (p. 46), Case 9, University I (p. 61). These are examples based on interviews with several universities, with names withheld. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/daigaku/minashi.pdf (checked against our copy of the original on 22 November 2026) ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
METI, "Q&A (for Universities and Research Institutions)" (in Japanese), February 2021. Q16, Q17, Q20. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/daigakuqanda/daigakuqanda.pdf (checked against our copy of the original on 22 November 2026). Its question numbers are separate from those of the Deemed Export Q&A. ↩ ↩2
-
School Education Act (Act No. 26 of 1947), Article 106. Checked against the current text through the e-Gov Laws API on 22 November 2026. https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/322AC0000000026 ↩
-
METI and MEXT, "Basic Framework and Points to Note for the Cross-Appointment System [Supplement]" (in Japanese), 2020 (posted by MEXT on 26 June 2020). In-place secondment form (p. 3), Table 2 comparing cross-appointments, side jobs and joint research (p. 11), safety and health (p. 21), sample list of items to coordinate within the university for a cross-appointment (sheets 48 and 49 of the PDF). https://www.mext.go.jp/content/20200626_mxt_sanchi01-mext_00750_1.pdf (posting page https://www.mext.go.jp/a_menu/shinkou/sangaku/mext_00750.html ; obtained and checked on 22 November 2026) ↩ ↩2
-
Employment Security Act (Act No. 141 of 1947), Article 5-5. Checked against the current text (version in force from 1 April 2026) through the e-Gov Laws API on 22 November 2026. https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/322AC0000000141 ↩
-
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, guidelines for employment placement businesses, employers recruiting workers and others on equal treatment, clear statement of working conditions, handling of job seekers' personal information and related matters (Ministry of Labour Notice No. 141 of 1999), Part 4, 1(1) (p. 6) of the version posted by the Ministry as last amended by MHLW Notice No. 143 of 2022. That version uses the article numbers before the Act was amended and refers to the handling of personal information as "Article 5-4 of the Act" (Article 5-5 in the current Act). https://www.mhlw.go.jp/content/000924131.pdf (obtained and checked on 22 November 2026) ↩






