TIMEWELL
Solutions
Free ConsultationContact Us
TIMEWELL

Unleashing organizational potential with AI

ISO/IEC 27001 (ISMS) certification mark (SGS / ISMS-AC)

ISO/IEC 27001:2022 certified Certificate No. JP26/00000255 Scope: Planning, development and operation of SaaS products utilizing AI technology

Services

  • ZEROCK
  • TRAFEED
  • TIMEWELL BASE
  • WARP
  • WARP 1Day
  • WARP NEXT Corporate
  • WARP BASIC
  • WARP ENTRE
  • Alumni Salon
  • WARP for Schools
  • Alumni Ventures
  • FDE
  • AI Consulting
  • EMC GLOBAL

Company

  • About Us
  • Team
  • Why TIMEWELL
  • News
  • Contact
  • Free Consultation

Content

  • Insights
  • Knowledge Base
  • Case Studies
  • Whitepapers
  • Events
  • Solutions
  • AI Readiness Check
  • ROI Calculator

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Manual Creator Extension
  • WARP Terms of Service
  • WARP NEXT School Rules
  • Legal Notice
  • Security
  • Anti-Social Policy
  • ZEROCK Terms of Service
  • TIMEWELL BASE Terms of Service

Newsletter

Get the latest AI and DX insights delivered weekly

Your email will only be used for newsletter delivery.

© 2026 株式会社TIMEWELL All rights reserved.

Contact Us
HomeTRAFEED MediaHow to Read BIS Settlement Orders and Use Them to Self-Assess Your Export Compliance Program
TRAFEED Media

How to Read BIS Settlement Orders and Use Them to Self-Assess Your Export Compliance Program

Published2026-11-22Checked against sources2026-11-22Ryuta Hamamoto
Export ControlBISEARSettlementCivil PenaltyVoluntary Self-DisclosureSelf-AssessmentInternal AuditExport ComplianceTRAFEED

How to read BIS settlement orders and proposed charging letters, what the aggravating and mitigating factors in 15 CFR Part 766 Supplement No. 1 actually say, how voluntary self-disclosure is treated, and a table that maps nine corporate settlements from 2023 to 2026 onto the checks they tested.

How to Read BIS Settlement Orders and Use Them to Self-Assess Your Export Compliance Program
Share

Hello, this is Ryuta Hamamoto from TIMEWELL.

Whenever the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) announces a large settlement, someone on the board tends to ask the head of export compliance the same thing: "If this happened here, where would we have caught it?" The news coverage gives you the company name and the penalty, and not much else. The orders themselves run long; the ones I read for this piece were between 15 and 72 pages. My short answer is this: read a settlement order for which layer of checks failed, not for who the company is, and map that layer onto a line in your own checklist. That turns an enforcement headline into self-assessment material.

I built the reading method and the mapping table below from the original text of nine corporate settlements that BIS published between April 2023 and October 2026. The regulations were checked against the eCFR (the online Code of Federal Regulations) as of 19 November 2026.

The conclusion first

  1. A settlement order can be read in four places: the violation count in the opening paragraph, the body of the charges, the WHEREAS paragraphs and the operative part. Look past the name and the amount for the provisions applied and the judgment the company got wrong.
  2. The penalty guidelines name aggravating factors (A to D), general factors that cut either way (E and F) and mitigating factors (G to I), and set the cap on the base penalty along two axes: egregious or not, and voluntarily disclosed or not. Disclosure halves the cap. It does not promise half the penalty.
  3. Put the layer each order tested (classification, screening, end use, records, training or audit) on a line of your checklist, score your own procedure and evidence against it, and keep the record.

One caveat before we start. This article does not judge any company. I do not name the companies in the orders; I describe them in general terms such as "a large U.S. equipment maker." A settlement order records how an administrative enforcement case was resolved, and the regulations say that agreeing to an order is solely for resolving the administrative claims and that BIS has neither the authority nor the responsibility for criminal proceedings (§766.18(d))1. Placement on the Entity List is a regulatory designation under U.S. export controls, not a judgment on the merits of the listed company. What we are after is not who did something wrong, but which check would have stopped it.

How a settlement order and a proposed charging letter are laid out

BIS posts its enforcement actions on the "Export Violations" page of its website2. Each entry has a case number (E3059, for example), a date and a PDF. Alongside settlements with companies, the list also carries renewals of Temporary Denial Orders (TDOs) and orders denying the export privileges of individuals convicted of offenses such as smuggling (under §766.25)3. For self-assessment, the corporate settlement orders are the ones that matter.

A case can be settled before a charging letter is served or after (§766.18(a) and (b))1. In a pre-service settlement, BIS prepares a proposed charging letter, and the settlement agreement and order go to the Assistant Secretary for Export Enforcement for approval. The record then consists of three documents: the proposed charging letter, the settlement agreement and the order (§766.20(a)). All nine corporate settlements I read were pre-service settlements under §766.18(a), and each PDF bound the order, the settlement agreement and the proposed charging letter together4.

A charging letter is a different document at a different stage. Section 766.3(a) calls it the formal complaint: it states that there is reason to believe a violation occurred, sets out the essential facts, cites the provisions involved and gives notice of the available sanctions. The respondent must answer within 30 days (§766.6(a)). If it does not, the administrative law judge, on BIS's motion, finds the facts to be as alleged (§766.7(a))1. A rule effective 2 June 2022 allows charging letters filed with an administrative law judge to be made public before the case is finally resolved (§766.20(c)(2)(ii))5. So a charging letter on the BIS site is the agency's allegation, not the outcome. Keep it separate from the settlement orders when you read.

Reading a settlement PDF in this order gets you to the substance quickly.

Where to read What it contains What to take for your self-assessment
Caption (In the Matter of, Respondent) The parties. A parent and a foreign subsidiary may both appear Whose conduct was charged. A subsidiary's conduct can be charged with the parent as respondent
Opening paragraph (has notified … alleges that … committed) The number of violations The count is not simply the number of transactions (see below)
Body of the charges (GENERAL ALLEGATIONS, STATEMENT OF CHARGES) Period, items (ECCN or EAR99), counterparties, value, the license requirement (§744.11 and so on), the type of violation (paragraphs of §764.2) The core text for identifying the layer of checks that was tested. It also describes how the company was reasoning
WHEREAS paragraphs Admission, cooperation, remediation, whether there was a voluntary disclosure How the mitigating factors (G and H) are actually described
Operative part (IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED) Penalty and payment deadline, suspended amounts, audit and training obligations, a suspended denial of export privileges, publication The level of compliance BIS required as a condition of settlement
Schedule of Violations (where attached) Date, item and value for each transaction Period and frequency. How many times the same error repeated

The violation count needs care. The guidelines say that for cases settled before a charging letter is filed with an administrative law judge, OEE will generally charge only the most serious violation per transaction (Supplement No. 1, III.A.4)6. On the other hand, the order of 2 October 2026 (E3059) treated each automatic software update as an export and counted 47 updates as 47 violations7. A large or small count partly reflects how the unit of a transaction was counted.

The type of violation is given by a paragraph of §764.28. Paragraph (a) is engaging in prohibited conduct, (b) is causing, aiding or abetting a violation, (e) is acting with knowledge of a violation, (g) is misrepresentation and concealment, (h) is evasion and (i) is failing to comply with reporting or recordkeeping requirements. The orders I read used (a), (b), (e), (h) and (i). Paragraph (b), for example, shows up when the conduct of a foreign subsidiary or a distributor is framed as having been caused by the parent or the manufacturer. The paragraph charged gives you a first idea of which layer was tested.

Before you use any of this, check how each order handles admission in the WHEREAS paragraphs. In all nine corporate settlements I could read as text, the company "admits committing the alleged conduct described in the Proposed Charging Letter" (one of them refers to "paragraphs number 1 through 24")4. None of the nine used "neither admits nor denies." I did not check orders from before 2023, so I cannot say whether the wording has changed over time. When you cite an order internally, quote its own wording. Note too that settled cases may not be reopened or appealed (§766.18(e)), and the settlement agreement I checked provides that the order has the same force and effect as a decision and order issued after a full administrative hearing (paragraph 7 of the E3059 agreement)17.

The aggravating and mitigating factors in the penalty guidelines, and how the base penalty is set

How the Office of Export Enforcement (OEE) sets a penalty in a settlement is described in Supplement No. 1 to Part 766, "Guidance on Charging and Penalty Determinations in Settlement of Administrative Enforcement Cases." The current version was last amended at 89 FR 75485 on 16 September 20246. The introduction says the guidance confers no rights, and that parties have no right to a settlement offer or particular terms regardless of the positions OEE has taken in other cases. It is guidance, not a formula.

Section II lists the possible responses to an apparent violation: no action, a warning letter, an administrative enforcement case started by a charging letter, a non-monetary penalty (such as a suspended denial order with training and compliance conditions), a civil monetary penalty, a criminal referral to the Department of Justice, other sanctions (revising, suspending or revoking licenses, denial of export privileges, exclusion from practice, training and audit requirements) and suspension or deferral of payment. The opening of Section III says that many apparent violations are isolated occurrences, good-faith misinterpretations or no more than simple negligence or carelessness, and that absent aggravating factors they may frequently be addressed with a no action letter or, if necessary, a warning letter6.

It helps to learn the factors by their original names, because that is how the orders talk.

Category Factor (original name) What it looks at (summary of the text)
Aggravating A. Willful or Reckless Violation of Law Willfulness, recklessness or gross negligence, concealment, pattern of conduct, prior notice, management involvement
Aggravating B. Awareness of Conduct at Issue Actual knowledge, reason to know, and whether senior management was involved or there was oversight meant to detect and prevent violations
Aggravating C. Harm to Regulatory Program Objectives Effect on U.S. national security and foreign policy. Sensitivity of the item, restrictions on the recipient, the licensing policy
Aggravating D. Failure to disclose a significant apparent violation A deliberate decision not to disclose a significant apparent violation the firm has identified
General E. Individual Characteristics Commercial sophistication, size of operations, volume and value of transactions, regulatory history, related illegal conduct, criminal convictions
General F. Compliance Program Whether a risk-based program existed at the time, its nature and adequacy, how far it follows BIS's Export Compliance Guidelines, whether it uncovered the problem
Mitigating G. Remedial Response Whether the conduct was stopped immediately, whether a VSD was filed, whether causes and extent were investigated, when senior management was told, new controls, a review for other violations
Mitigating H. Exceptional Cooperation with OEE Timely and complete information including overseas records, disclosure of related violations, agreeing to toll the statute of limitations
Mitigating I. License Was Likely To Be Approved Whether a license would likely have been granted, or a license exception was available
Case by case J to N Related violations (J), multiple unrelated violations (K), other enforcement action (L), future compliance and deterrence (M), other factors OEE deems relevant (N)

For self-assessment, the pair that matters most is F and D. Factor F credits a program that uncovered a problem and prevented further violations, and it also looks at whether a firm deliberately failed to disclose a significant apparent violation that its own program uncovered6. If your controls find a problem and the finding is then sat on, the same controls become an aggravating factor. I set out the steps from discovery to the disclosure decision in a table later on.

The cap on the base penalty comes from this matrix (IV.B.2)6.

Voluntary self-disclosure No voluntary self-disclosure
Non-egregious case (1) Up to one-half of the transaction value (2) Up to the transaction value
Egregious case (3) Up to one-half of the applicable statutory maximum (4) Up to the applicable statutory maximum

The statutory maximum is the per-violation amount under the Export Control Reform Act (ECRA). The Supplement gives the 2024 figure as $364,992, "or an amount that is twice the value of the transaction that is the basis of the violation," whichever is greater. The current 15 CFR §6.3(c)(6) adjusts that figure to $374,4749. The OEE Director decides whether a case is egregious. Section IV.B.1 says substantial weight will generally go to Factors A, B, C and D, with particular emphasis on A, B and C. Oddly, the same sentence labels D as "individual characteristics," whereas in Section III Factor D is the failure to disclose and individual characteristics is E. Since that is an inconsistency in the text itself, I would only rely on the second half, "particular emphasis on Factors A, B, and C," when you explain this internally.

The base amount is then adjusted up or down by the Section III factors (IV.B.2.b), and penalties in settlements reached after litigation begins will usually be higher than the guidelines describe (IV.A)6. Orders do not show the base penalty calculation. The order of 11 February 2026 (E3045) imposed $252,500,300, exactly twice the roughly $126,250,150 value of the items in the proposed charging letter, and the BIS announcement that day described it as twice the transaction value and the maximum allowed by statute10. At the other end, the order of 2 October 2026 (E3059) fully suspended payment of a $2,000,000 penalty for one year, to be waived if the conditions are met. A footnote in that order says the suspension was based on a demonstrated limited ability to pay, in accordance with the penalty guidance7. That is the suspension and deferral logic in Section II.H, and it should not be mistaken for the effect of the voluntary disclosure in that case.

Replace siloed classification work with AI.

METI's FY2024 data shows 52% of foreign exchange law violations stem from classification errors. Download the TRAFEED product catalog covering features and rollout.

Download Product CatalogContact About TRAFEED

Mapping the orders onto your own layers of checks

This is where the self-assessment happens. From the body of the charges, pull out what the company was doing and how it was reasoning, decide which layer of checks that belongs to, and rephrase it as a question about your own company. The last column refers to the item numbers in our 20-item export control self-assessment. I identify orders by case number and date rather than company name.

Layer of checks What the order says (companies described in general terms) Case Question for your company Item
Classification (is it U.S.-origin?) A large U.S. equipment maker began production in the United States, did assembly and testing at a foreign subsidiary, and reexported to a customer on the Entity List. Its trade group concluded the equipment became foreign-made under the customs concept of "substantial transformation." The order says that concept does not appear anywhere in the EAR. Blocks in the export compliance system were manually overridden on the basis of an internal checklist E3045 (11 February 2026) Are you deciding "subject to the EAR" with customs origin rules? Who may override a system block, and is each override recorded? 5, 6, 12
Classification (de minimis valuation) A U.S. instrument maker calculated the U.S. content for de minimis purposes using the value of a component rather than the complete product it actually shipped. The company found this itself and voluntarily disclosed it. A pricing arrangement designed in part to push U.S. content below 25 percent was charged once as evasion (§764.2(h)) E3047 (26 February 2026) Does your procedure fix the unit of calculation (the product as shipped) and the value (fair market price)? Do you keep each version of the calculation? 5, 6
Classification (foreign direct product rule) A large European components maker made EAR99 products at its own plants outside the United States and sold them to a customer on the Entity List. The production equipment was a direct product of U.S. technology, which brought the products within the foreign direct product rule (FDPR), but internal advice confused de minimis with the FDPR and concluded there was no impact. That advice was not independently reviewed even after warnings and certification requests arrived from suppliers E3052 (16 June 2026) Who reviews interpretive advice on the rules, and how often? Is there a route that sends supplier warnings and certification requests to export compliance? 7, 11, 20
Screening (address-only entries) A U.S. instrument maker shipped eight times to an overseas address that had been added to the Entity List as an address-only entry in the June 2024 change. It had asked its screening software vendor about the change, but an employee first noticed a relevant alert in February 2025 E3047 Does your screening cover listed addresses, not just names? Do you have your own record of checking changes to your screening tool? 9
Screening (affiliates and ongoing supply) A U.S. software company issued software licenses (EAR99) through a Japanese distributor to a Japanese affiliate that has been on the Entity List since 2019, then kept up maintenance contracts and automatic updates. The license documents named the Japanese affiliate as licensee. There were no written export compliance procedures, and no one was trained or specifically tasked with export compliance E3059 (2 October 2026) Do you screen at every maintenance renewal, update and license renewal, not only on new orders? Do you check whether a domestic counterparty is a listed company's affiliate? 8, 9, 13
End use and red flags A U.S. parts maker with nine employees shipped parts (EAR99) that needed a license for Russia under the HTS code requirements, partly through third-country distributors. It screened the customer against the Consolidated Screening List with no hits. After its bank said it would not process the wire payments, the shipping letters of instruction began naming a distributor as ultimate consignee, and shipments continued E3054 (24 August 2026) After a "no hit," do you still check country-specific license requirements by item and warnings from banks and logistics providers? 8, 12, 20
Spare parts and export filings A U.S. machine tool maker sold spare parts (EAR99) to authorized distributors, which used them to service machines owned by Entity List parties. For inaccurate Electronic Export Information (EEI) filed by a Russian distributor through its freight forwarder, the maker had no written agreement making the distributor responsible, so the maker kept responsibility for the accuracy of the filings E2983 (17 January 2025) Do you know the final customer for spare parts sold through distributors? When someone else files for you, is the allocation of responsibility in writing? 4, 8, 17
Foreign subsidiaries The Chinese subsidiary of a European engineering company arranged in-country transfers of EAR99 equipment to a party on the Entity List. The order names the group's German management company as respondent and charges it with causing the violations (§764.2(b)) E3044 (7 January 2026) Do your foreign subsidiaries handle items subject to the EAR in local procurement or installation work? 4, 10
Records (license conditions) The Chinese subsidiary of a U.S. instrument maker did not keep the demonstration records required by a license condition (date, license identifier, name and general location of the party, model and serial numbers) E3047 Do you have a ledger that keeps license conditions met after shipment? 12, 17

Building the table left me with three observations.

First, most of the classification errors began with a misreading of the rules, and nobody inside the company went back and reread it. E3045 brought a customs concept into the EAR, E3052 mixed up de minimis and the FDPR, and E3047 used a component as the unit of valuation. None of these is described as starting from bad intent. Even so, the E3052 order says internal controls were insufficient to ensure that compliance advice was broadly distributed and independently reviewed or reassessed11. What a self-assessment should test is less whether a classification was right than whether someone else rereads the interpretation behind it on a regular basis. The E3045 order also notes that labor costs are not relevant to the de minimis analysis10. It is worth checking whether your internal checklists measure things the regulations do not.

Second, "did we screen the name?" is no longer enough. Address-only entries, affiliates of listed companies (including in Japan), ongoing supply such as maintenance and automatic updates, and the customer beyond a distributor all sit outside a simple name check. Even with a record that screening was done, a mismatch in what was screened, or when, means nothing stops. In E3054 the customer came back clean on the Consolidated Screening List, but the country rules (the HTS-based license requirement for Russia) and the warning from the bank were separate layers. You can close much of this gap by recording not only "which list, which version, when" but also "against name, address or affiliate." The eleven fields of a screening record and a rescreening ledger are in our counterparty screening record kit (Excel, in Japanese).

Third, the settlement conditions themselves tell you what BIS thought was missing. The E3059 order requires at least two employees or officers designated to handle export compliance, export compliance training within three months, and an internal audit, completed within nine months, of the six months after the order7. The E3045 order requires two annual internal audits covering semiconductor manufacturing equipment exports to or within China, with reports due by 1 July 2027 and 1 July 2028, and a three-year denial of export privileges suspended on condition of payment and timely audits10. The E2983 order required two external audits by an unaffiliated third-party consultant with expertise in U.S. export controls12. Each audit has to be in substantial compliance with the sample audit module in BIS's Export Compliance Guidelines, which list eight elements of an effective program: management commitment, risk assessment, export authorization, recordkeeping, training, audits, handling export violations and taking corrective actions, and building and maintaining the program13. If you are testing the training layer, the role-based scripts and attendance record template in our internal export control training kit (Word, in Japanese) give you evidence in the right shape.

If you export from Japan or run plants there, first pin down where the EAR reaches reexports from Japan and products made in Japan; that is how you tell which rows of the table are about you. The site-by-site check is in reexports from overseas subsidiaries under the EAR, and self-check forms and an audit plan for overseas sites are in our group and overseas site governance set (Excel, in Japanese).

How voluntary self-disclosure is treated, and what it does to the penalty

Voluntary self-disclosure (VSD) is the part of a settlement order people misread most often. Here it is in the strength of the original wording.

Section 764.5(a) says BIS "strongly encourages" disclosure to OEE if you believe you may have violated the EAR. It then says that voluntary self-disclosure is a mitigating factor, and that a firm's deliberate decision not to disclose significant apparent violations is an aggravating factor8. That is strong language. The limitations in paragraph (b) are narrow, though. A disclosure counts only if OEE receives it before OEE or another U.S. agency has learned the same or substantially similar information from another source and started an investigation ((b)(3)). The weight given to it is solely within OEE's discretion, it may be outweighed by aggravating factors, and it does not prevent a referral to the Department of Justice ((b)(4)). And a firm is not treated as having disclosed unless the person disclosing did so with the full knowledge and authorization of senior management ((b)(5)). Read together, the rule is not "disclose and it will be lighter." It is "only disclosures made early, with senior management's approval, count as a mitigating factor."

The procedure splits by severity. A minor or technical violation is defined as one that does not contain any aggravating factors as defined in section III(A) of Supplement No. 1. The examples given are immaterial EEI filing errors, inadvertent recordkeeping violations from failed file retrieval or retention (flood, fire, malware and the like), and using one license exception where other license exceptions were available ((c)(1))8. These go in an abbreviated narrative report by email, and violations from the preceding quarter can be bundled ((c)(2) and (3)). OEE will generally resolve them within 60 days of the final submission with a no action notice or a warning letter ((e)(1)). A significant violation is one involving aggravating factors, and if you are unsure which you have, the rule tells you to follow the procedure for a significant violation ((d)(1)).

For significant violations the clock is specific. Make an initial notification as soon as possible after discovery ((d)(1) and (2)), and get the full narrative account to OEE within 180 days of the date OEE receives the initial notification ((d)(2)(iii)). Missing that deadline is not an additional violation, but it may reduce or eliminate the mitigating effect of the disclosure. Extensions must be requested before the deadline, showing among other things that the review began promptly ((d)(2)(iv)). OEE recommends that the review cover five years before the date of the initial notification ((d)(3)). The narrative covers the kind of violation, when and how it happened, the identities and addresses of everyone involved, license numbers, a description of the items with quantity, U.S. dollar value and ECCN, and any mitigating circumstances. It comes with licensing and shipping documents and a certification, signed by an authorized official, that the representations are true and correct ((d)(3) to (5)). The prohibition on false statements in §764.2(g) applies to that certification.

The effect on the money follows the matrix in the previous section. A disclosure halves the cap on the base penalty and feeds into the assessment of remedial response (G) and cooperation (H). Both are caps, "up to," and neither promises half. The orders bear this out: disclosure is not written up as a way out of a penalty. In E3052, the WHEREAS paragraphs say the company immediately halted related transactions on identifying the conduct, engaged external counsel to conduct a review, timely filed a VSD and fully cooperated with OEE, and the penalty was still $36,184,680. Of that, $3,601,029 was suspended until the company pays the same amount as disgorgement under its agreement with the Department of Justice, and is then credited11. E3047 and E3059 also ended in settlement orders after voluntary disclosures714. The E3054 order, by contrast, does not mention a voluntary disclosure; it recites full cooperation and remediation such as stronger screening, transaction review, escalation and recordkeeping15.

When you find a possible violation in-house, recording the decision in this order lets you explain later who decided what, when and on what basis. The deadlines are from the regulations; the record fields are our own suggestion.

Step What to do Basis What to record
1 Day of discovery Stop the related transactions Supplement No. 1, III.G.1 Date and person who found it, transactions stopped
2 Report to management Decide on disclosure with senior management's authorization §764.5(b)(5), III.G.2 Date reported, who approved, the reasoning
3 Initial notification For a suspected significant violation, notify as soon as possible §764.5(d)(1) and (2) Date OEE received it (the start of the 180 days)
4 Look-back review Review transactions going back five years (recommended) §764.5(d)(3) Scope, method, owner
5 Full narrative Submit within 180 days; request any extension before the deadline §764.5(d)(2)(iii) and (iv) Date submitted, any extension, who signed the certification
6 Remediation Investigate causes and extent, fix controls, train III.G.2 to 4 Plan and evidence of completion
7 Japan Decide separately whether a report is needed under Japanese law Ministerial Ordinance on Export Compliance Standards The decision and its basis

The last row is a separate decision from the U.S. process. In Japan, exporters of listed items must, when they have violated or may have violated the relevant laws, promptly report to the Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry and take the measures needed to prevent recurrence (Ministerial Ordinance on Export Compliance Standards, Article 1, item 2(nu))16. METI's Security Export Control Guidance [Introductory Edition] says that a voluntary report of a violation to METI may be taken into account in the disposition17. The Japanese penalties and the structure behind them are covered in our 20-item self-assessment. The same transaction can fall under both countries' rules, so do not close the disclosure decision in one country alone.

Keeping a record of the self-assessment

If you read the orders and stop there, next year's board report will look like this year's. Turn the mapping into a record you can score. A third party should be able to read it and see which order, which layer, what you checked in your own company and on what evidence. These fields are the minimum I would suggest.

Field What to write Tip
Order Case number, date of the order, date retrieved Tracking by number rather than company name keeps names out of internal papers
Provisions and type The license requirement (§744.11 and so on) and the paragraph of §764.2 The paragraph points to the layer that was tested
Layer tested Classification, screening, end use, records, training or audit One order can yield two or more layers
Your procedure The section and version of the relevant rule or procedure If there is none, write "none"
Evidence The three most recent records (classification sheets, screening logs, training rosters) If you cannot pull three, do not give the top score
Score ◎ ○ △ × (the same scale as the 20-item self-assessment) At least two assessors, including someone outside export compliance
Corrective action What, by when, who (a named person) Use a date
Next review Date Also review when the rules change or a similar order appears

To show the shape, here is one row filled in with a fictional example. It is not a real company's record.

Order Provisions and type Layer Your procedure Evidence Score Corrective action
E3047 (26 February 2026, retrieved 22 November 2026) §744.16 (address entries), §764.2(a) Screening Screening procedure v3, section 5 (screens by name) No address field in the last three screening records △ Add listed addresses to screening and keep a record of checking the tool's settings in-house (by 20 December, named owner)

I suggest reading the list once a quarter. Pick one or two of the new corporate settlements that are closest to your items or the shape of your trade, and add a line each to the record. That cadence is our own working rule of thumb, not an official standard. For the board, one line per order is enough.

Template (one line for a board report; replace the details with your own results) In a BIS settlement (E3047, February 2026), shipments to a party listed by address only were at issue. We screen by name only and scored this △. We will add address screening by 20 December and show the evidence in the next report.

Put the scores in the same sheet as the 20-item self-assessment so the change from last time is visible at a glance. Our export control self-assessment: 20 items and a one-page board report (Excel, in Japanese) has the scoring, scores by area, the one-page board report and a 90-day plan in one file. If you tie each layer from an order to an item number in that sheet, you can present U.S. enforcement developments as movement in a score built on Japan's compliance standards. When a U.S. rule itself changes, run the first-day triage separately from reading orders. Our U.S. rule change impact triage sheet (Excel, in Japanese) has sheets for listing deadlines, six applicability questions, case-by-case triage, a one-page executive brief and the decision record.

One more suggestion: feed the record back into training. BIS's Export Compliance Guidelines describe finding and fixing a problem internally as a "lessons learned" training opportunity13. Another company's order is easier to discuss in-house precisely because it is not your own violation. Put the facts of an order on one page without the company name and ask sales, engineering and logistics where your own process would have stopped it. People remember that far better than a read-through of the procedures manual.

Also readScreening Entity List Address-Only Entries: Testing and Documenting Your Screening Tool SettingsHow do you turn the settlement over shipments to a listed address into tests and records for your screening tool?

Summary, and what we have not confirmed

Read as a story about a company name and a dollar figure, a settlement order ends as someone else's misfortune. Pull out how the company was reasoning, put it back on a layer of checks, and it becomes a question about your own procedures and evidence. The guideline factors explain why a given failure weighs heavily. Voluntary self-disclosure counts as a mitigating factor only when it is made early and with senior management's approval; it is not a way to avoid a penalty. Honestly, every time I read one of these orders, what worries me is less the misreading of the rule than the absence of anyone rereading it.

Here is what I had not been able to confirm as of 22 November 2026.

  • The admission wording in orders before 2023. I did not check whether any of them used "neither admits nor denies."
  • Every entry on the 2025 and 2026 list. The analysis rests on the nine corporate settlements I could read as text. Some orders on the list are image-only PDFs, and I did not check their admission wording.
  • The base penalty calculation for individual orders. The orders do not show it, so whether a case was treated as egregious, and how much each factor moved the amount, cannot be read from the published documents.
  • Why Section IV.B.1 of Supplement No. 1 labels Factor D differently from Section III.
  • Treatment under Japan's Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act. Whether the same transaction needs a Japanese license is outside the scope of this article.
  • BIS's Export Compliance Guidelines date from 2016, before the 2024 amendment of Supplement No. 1. On the effect of a voluntary disclosure, rely on the current Supplement No. 1 and §764.5.

This article is a general summary, not advice on any individual case. If you become aware of a possible violation, work with your internal compliance lead and specialists in U.S. law. I will update this article when the rules or the guidance change.

What to read next

  • The 20-item export control self-assessment: the scoring sheet and one-page board report that the rows of this article feed into.
  • Japan export control violation cases: the history of cases under Japan's Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act.
  • Reexports from overseas subsidiaries under the EAR: a site-by-site check of de minimis and the FDPR.
  • The FDPR (foreign direct product rule) explained: how the EAR reaches products made outside the United States.
  • Tracking Entity List and SDN updates weekly: following listing changes through the Federal Register and the CSL.
  • Customer due diligence (end-user screening) in practice: what to check after the list screening.
  • Export control governance for group companies and overseas subsidiaries: self-checks and audit plans for foreign subsidiaries.
  • Designing internal export control training: 30 minutes by role and a ten-question test.

If you want counterparty screening and the record of each decision in one workflow, take a look at TRAFEED. You can reach us here.

Footnotes

  1. 15 CFR Part 766 (Administrative Enforcement Proceedings), §766.3, §766.6, §766.7, §766.18, §766.20 and §766.25. Retrieved through the eCFR versioner API (version as of 19 November 2026) and checked on 22 November 2026. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-766 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  2. BIS, "Export Violations" (list of enforcement actions with case number, name, date and PDF). Retrieved 22 November 2026. https://www.bis.gov/enforcement/export-violations ↩

  3. For example, an order denying the export privileges of a convicted individual under §766.25 and 50 U.S.C. 4819(e) (90 FR 54298, 26 November 2025). Federal Register text checked on 22 November 2026. https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2025-21105 ↩

  4. Nine corporate settlements on the BIS "Export Violations" list: E2836 (19 April 2023), E2983 (17 January 2025), E2995 (27 June 2025), E3044 (7 January 2026), E3045 (11 February 2026), E3047 (26 February 2026), E3052 (16 June 2026), E3054 (24 August 2026) and E3059 (2 October 2026). Orders, settlement agreements and proposed charging letters retrieved on 22 November 2026; the admission wording in the WHEREAS paragraphs and settlement under §766.18(a) were checked in each. ↩ ↩2

  5. BIS final rule (87 FR 34131, published 6 June 2022, effective 2 June 2022), revision of §766.20(c)(2)(ii) allowing charging letters filed with an administrative law judge to be made public before final disposition. Federal Register text checked on 22 November 2026. https://www.federalregister.gov/d/2022-11885 ↩

  6. 15 CFR Part 766, Supplement No. 1, "Guidance on Charging and Penalty Determinations in Settlement of Administrative Enforcement Cases" (Introduction and Sections I to IV; last amended 89 FR 75485, 16 September 2024). eCFR version as of 19 November 2026, checked on 22 November 2026. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-766 ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6

  7. BIS "Export Violations," case E3059 (2 October 2026): order, settlement agreement and proposed charging letter. 66 violations (11 under §764.2(e), 55 under (a)); each automatic update treated as an export; voluntary disclosure (initial disclosure 2 July 2025, VSD 31 October 2025); full one-year suspension of the $2,000,000 penalty and footnote 6 on ability to pay; two designated personnel, training within three months and an internal audit within nine months; paragraph 7 of the agreement. Checked against the original on 22 November 2026 (image pages read visually). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

  8. 15 CFR Part 764, §764.2 (Violations), §764.3 (Sanctions) and §764.5 (Voluntary self-disclosure; last amended 89 FR 75482, 16 September 2024). eCFR version as of 19 November 2026, checked on 22 November 2026. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-B/chapter-VII/subchapter-C/part-764 ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  9. 15 CFR §6.3(c)(6) (50 U.S.C. 4819; per-violation maximum adjusted from $364,992 to $374,474). eCFR version as of 19 November 2026, checked on 22 November 2026. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-A/part-6/section-6.3 ↩

  10. BIS "Export Violations," case E3045 (11 February 2026): order, settlement agreement and proposed charging letter (https://www.bis.gov/media/2587 ). 56 violations; items valued at about $126,250,150; penalty of $252,500,300; the conclusions on "substantial transformation"; footnote 16 on labor costs; two annual internal audits (reports due 1 July 2027 and 1 July 2028); three-year suspended denial. Checked on 22 November 2026 together with BIS's announcement of the same day (describing the penalty as twice the transaction value and the statutory maximum). ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  11. BIS "Export Violations," case E3052 (16 June 2026): order, settlement agreement and proposed charging letter. 109 violations; confusion between the FDPR and de minimis; the statement on internal controls; warnings and certifications from suppliers; the recitals on VSD, full cooperation and remediation; penalty of $36,184,680 with $3,601,029 suspended pending disgorgement under the agreement with the Department of Justice. Checked on 22 November 2026. ↩ ↩2

  12. BIS "Export Violations," case E2983 (17 January 2025): order, settlement agreement and proposed charging letter (https://www.bis.gov/media/1453 ). Sales of spare parts; Charge 42 on responsibility for EEI; two external audits by an unaffiliated third party. Checked on 22 November 2026. ↩

  13. BIS, "Export Compliance Guidelines: The Elements of an Effective Export Compliance Program" (2016; the eight elements, Element 7 and the Audit Module at page 35). Retrieved and checked on 22 November 2026. https://media.bis.gov/sites/default/files/documents/ECP_0.pdf ↩ ↩2

  14. BIS "Export Violations," case E3047 (26 February 2026): order, settlement agreement and proposed charging letter (https://www.bis.gov/media/2593 ). 19 violations (9 under §764.2(b), 1 under (h), 1 under (i), 8 under (a)); de minimis calculations and voluntary disclosure; shipments to an address-only entry; records required by a license condition; penalty of $1,000,000. Checked on 22 November 2026. ↩

  15. BIS "Export Violations," case E3054 (24 August 2026): order, settlement agreement and proposed charging letter. 10 violations (8 under §764.2(a), 2 under (e)); the HTS-based license requirement for Russia; screening against the Consolidated Screening List; the bank's notice; the shipping letters of instruction; the recitals on full cooperation and remediation; penalty of $1,000,000 payable within 30 days. Checked on 22 November 2026. The order in E3044 (7 January 2026, https://www.bis.gov/media/2572 ) was checked the same day. ↩

  16. Ministerial Ordinance on Export Compliance Standards (METI Ordinance No. 60 of 2009), Article 1, item 2(nu). Current version reflecting the amendment effective 9 October 2025, retrieved through the e-Gov Law API (v2) and checked on 22 November 2026. https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/421M60000400060 ↩

  17. METI, Security Export Control Guidance [Introductory Edition], version 3.0 (March 2026), Chapter 2, Section VII, "Penalties for violations of laws and regulations" (page 31). Checked against a copy retrieved on 20 November 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/guidance/guidance.pdf ↩

This article was produced with the help of AI. A human verified the primary sources and edited the text before publication.

Read next

Articles that answer the question you are likely to have next.

  1. 1Export Control Self-Assessment: 20 Items to Score Your Program and Report to the BoardHow do you turn the checks an order tested into a score for your own program?
  2. 2Screening Entity List Address-Only Entries: Testing and Documenting Your Screening Tool SettingsHow do you turn the settlement over shipments to a listed address into tests and records for your screening tool?
  3. 3Reexports From Overseas Subsidiaries Under the EAR: Checking De Minimis and FDPR Site by SiteHow do you check, site by site, how far U.S. rules reach shipments from overseas subsidiaries?

This article is part of TRAFEED Media, our practical media on export controls and economic security

Back to TRAFEED MediaThis week's regulatory updates

52% of FY2024 export-control violations stem from classification errors. Is your team covered?

METI FY2024 data shows over half of violations stem from classification. Start with a free 5-question light check (~2 min, no email), then continue to the full 10-question report.

Contact About TRAFEED
Contact About TRAFEEDContact form (about 3 min)TRAFEED product briefFeatures & rollout in PDF

Share this article if you found it useful

Share

Newsletter

Get the latest AI and DX insights delivered weekly

Your email will only be used for newsletter delivery.

Free download

Recommended materials

China MOFCOM Lists (Control & Watch): 80-Entity Reference Sheet (through the 29 Jun 2026 wave)

All 80 entities on China MOFCOM's Control List and Watch List, in official / Chinese / English names. Being listed is a regulatory designation, not a judgment of the company — useful both for counterparty screening and for listed companies to understand where they stand. Based on primary sources (Announcements No. 11/12/27/28); as of 20 November 2026 there had been no additions or removals (checked through No. 56).

The BIS Affiliates Rule (50 Percent Rule) Readiness Checklist (2026)

A fill-in working checklist for trade compliance teams preparing for the BIS Affiliates Rule. Covers what the rule actually does (aggregation across owners and across lists, cascade/carry-forward, the rule of most restrictiveness, and why exactly 50% is in while below 50% is not automatically out), what is stayed and what is in effect now, where ownership data typically breaks, and a six-phase preparation list from scoping through governance. The stay was due to end on 9 November 2026; on that day BIS published a rule extending it to 10 January 2027 (91 FR 70789). The sheet is built to work whether the rule then returns, is stayed again, or is modified (as of 21 November 2026). Based on primary sources (90 FR 47201, 90 FR 50857, 91 FR 70789, 15 CFR, and China's Ministry of Commerce). Designation is a regulatory classification, not a judgement about a company; final determinations rest with your export-control officer and the authorities' current guidance.

EAR Classification Flow & EAR99 Practical Checklist (for exporters from Japan, 2026)

A fill-in working sheet covering "subject to the EAR? → ECCN on the CCL? → EAR99?", the crucial "when EAR99 still needs a license" (embargoes, end-use, end-user), de minimis / FDP, counterparty screening, and the two-track cross-check with Japan's classification (FEFTA / Appended Table 1). Based on primary sources (15 CFR, the Federal Register, BIS, METI); the EAR changes frequently, so treat the authorities' latest guidance and your export-control officer as authoritative.

See all materials

Related Knowledge Base

Export Control Guide

Solutions

Strengthen Export ComplianceStreamline compliance with complex export regulations

Talk with us about export-control operations

Share your screening, classification, or compliance workflow. We will map where TRAFEED can help—via our contact form (no cold booking).

Contact UsDownload Catalog

Related Articles

U.S. Export Rule Change Playbook: Read the Federal Register and Triage Impact in Three Hours

U.S. Export Rule Change Playbook: Read the Federal Register and Triage Impact in Three Hours

A playbook for the day a BIS rule lands, worked through on the 19 November 2026 interim final rule: read the Federal Register, triage impact in three hours, and brief management on one page.

2026-11-20
Export Control Self-Assessment: 20 Items to Score Your Program and Report to the Board

Export Control Self-Assessment: 20 Items to Score Your Program and Report to the Board

A 20-item checklist tied to Japan's Export Compliance Standards for scoring your export control program, finding gaps and reporting them to the board on one page, with penalties and a 90-day plan.

2026-11-20
What Is an ECCN? How to Read the Code and Look Up Your Product's ECCN (2026)

What Is an ECCN? How to Read the Code and Look Up Your Product's ECCN (2026)

What an ECCN means, how to read codes like 3A001 and 5A992.c, and three ways to look up your product's ECCN, checked against the EAR as of October 2026.

2026-04-24
BIS Advanced Computing Guidance (May 31, 2026): How the D:5 Headquarters Test Changes AI Chip and Data Center Transactions

BIS Advanced Computing Guidance (May 31, 2026): How the D:5 Headquarters Test Changes AI Chip and Data Center Transactions

On May 31, 2026, the U.S. Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) published a short piece of guidance on the license requirements for advanced computing items[^1].

2026-06-01
Screening Entity List Address-Only Entries: Testing and Documenting Your Screening Tool Settings

Screening Entity List Address-Only Entries: Testing and Documenting Your Screening Tool Settings

The U.S. Entity List has 19 entries that list only an address, with no company name (eCFR as of November 19, 2026). This piece covers the June 2024 rule and how 15 CFR 744.11 and 744.16 work, why name-only screening misses these entries (settlement E3047), eight tests to confirm your screening tool settings with a record template, and how to re-screen past shipments.

2026-11-22
When a Foundry Asks for Your Location and Ultimate Parent: A Reply Guide for IC Designers

When a Foundry Asks for Your Location and Ultimate Parent: A Reply Guide for IC Designers

For fabless and IC design companies asked by a foundry or OSAT about their headquarters, location and ultimate parent, or about agreeing to information the foundry reports to BIS. I map each request to Note 1 to ECCN 3A090.a, 15 CFR 743.9 and the KYC vetting form, explain the approved IC designer application, December 31, 2026 and the 180 days, and give reply templates and a record format.

2026-11-22