Hello, this is Ryuta Hamamoto from TIMEWELL.
A salesperson comes to your desk and asks, "The end-user field for this customer is still blank. Can we ship anyway?" If you handle export control on top of another job, are you the one who gets to say yes? My answer is no. Put the final decision on concern cases with a director (or similar) who is independent of sales, and keep your own role to stopping the case and assembling the facts. That is the arrangement METI's Introductory Guidance and the ministerial notice on internal compliance rules describe. It is not, however, something the text of the Export Compliance Standards ordinance requires directly. Once you separate obligations from recommendations, even a mid-sized company with only a few directors can set up a workable split.
The short version
- The term "transaction review officer" does not appear in the Export Compliance Standards ordinance. The ordinance requires a classification officer and an overall officer, defined authority and responsibility for departments, and procedures for confirming end use and end users. The transaction review officer is how METI's Introductory Guidance (p. 49), the ministerial notice and METI's Q&A on internal compliance programs (CPs) describe the system and the CP.
- The transaction review officer is expected to be chosen from among directors or similar, and a position independent of sales is recommended. For companies short on people, the representative director may also double as chief officer.
- Your job as dual-role staff is to stop the case, sort out the facts and whether a license is needed, and keep the record. If you delegate final authority to staff, limit the scope and write the delegate and the scope into your rules (a point METI raised in its fiscal 2024 on-site inspections).
By "concern" I mean a counterparty check that leaves something unclear or something that needs confirming. It is not a verdict on the counterparty. Being listed on METI's End User List or a similar list is a regulatory designation, not a judgment on whether that company is good or bad. I am not suggesting anyone sort counterparties or people by nationality or origin.
The overall 30-day plan and how to fill in the five-point counterparty sheet are in my piece on the first 30 days of a dual-role job. This article takes one part of its role table, "who stops the deal and who decides when a concern comes up," and goes deeper.
What the Compliance Standards require and what a CP is expected to contain
Start by separating two layers. The first is the Export Compliance Standards under Article 55-10 of the Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act (FEFTA). Paragraph 4 of that article says exporters "shall conduct exports, etc. in accordance with the Export Compliance Standards." It applies to anyone who exports as a business, whether or not they have internal rules1. The second layer is the internal compliance program (CP). METI's Q&A on CPs says drafting and filing a CP is voluntary (Q2), and that the compliance standards must be followed regardless of whether a company has drafted a CP (Q3)2. The Introductory Guidance also describes a CP as "not a legal regulation, but a voluntary measure to strengthen self-management" (p. 50)3.
So what does the compliance standards ordinance say about officers? Reading the current text on e-Gov (the version in force from October 9, 2025), only two officers are named4. (The ordinance labels its sub-items with Japanese kana, イ, ロ, ハ, ニ and so on. I write them as (i), (ro), (ha), (ni).)
| Provision | What it requires | Who it applies to |
|---|---|---|
| Art. 1, item 1 (i) | Appoint an officer responsible for classification confirmation (the classification officer) | Everyone who exports as a business |
| Art. 1, item 2 (i) | Appoint, "from among those who represent" the exporter, an officer who oversees export work (the overall officer) | Exporters of specified critical goods, etc. |
| Art. 1, item 2 (ro) | Set the authority and responsibility of departments doing export work, and the relationship between them where several are involved | Same |
| Art. 1, item 2 (ni) | Set procedures for confirming end use and end users, etc., and confirm them according to those procedures | Same |
| Art. 2 | The same person may be appointed classification officer and overall officer | Same |
Nowhere does the text say "transaction review officer." The word "transaction review" itself does not appear. According to the CP Q&A (note 2 to Q3), exporters of specified critical goods, etc. are those who export list-controlled goods or technology (items 1 to 15 of Appended Table 1 of the Export Trade Control Order and the Appended Table of the Foreign Exchange Order)2. Article 4 also provides that item 2 (i) to (ri) of Article 1 does not apply to those whose only business is transactions designated by the Minister under Article 17(8) of the Foreign Exchange Order, or exports in the cases listed in Article 4(1) of the Export Trade Control Order4.
The transaction review officer, by contrast, is part of the system the Introductory Guidance lays out in Chapter 4, "Building an export control system" (p. 49)3. Paragraph (2)③ of the ministerial notice on internal compliance rules (June 24, 1994, No. 6-Bō-604) calls for "a director or above" to be "the final decision-maker in transaction reviews of controlled goods, etc.," and Q14 of the CP Q&A deals with the final decision-maker in a CP52. In other words, the transaction review officer sits in the layer of system design and the CP, not in the layer of legal obligations.
| Role | Compliance standards ordinance (obligation) | Introductory Guidance, ministerial notice, CP Q&A (system and CP) |
|---|---|---|
| Chief officer (overall officer) | Art. 1, item 2 (i). Chosen from among those who represent the company | Guidance p. 49: the representative director "must be designated as chief officer." Q13: in principle the representative director (with an exception). The note to Q13 says the CP chief officer corresponds to the overall officer under the standards |
| Classification officer | Art. 1, item 1 (i). All exporters | Guidance p. 49: "must be appointed." Q36: for the classification officer field in the CL, anyone inside the organization may be named, with no restriction on department or title |
| Transaction review officer | No provision | Guidance p. 49: "expected to be chosen from among directors or similar." Ministerial notice (2)③: "a director or above." Q14 describes the notice as requiring "officers or above" |
| Shipment control officer | No provision (confirming identity at shipment is an obligation under Art. 1, item 2 (ho)) | Guidance p. 49: "there is no rule requiring one, but appointing one is recommended" |
Here is my own reading. Even though the ordinance never names a transaction review officer, item 2 (ro) requires you to set departments' authority and responsibility, and item 2 (ni) requires procedures for confirming end use and end users. Who decides a concern case is exactly what those two provisions are about. Even if you have not filed a CP, I think the straightforward way to meet the text is to write down who decides.
A word on the nature of the ministerial notice. It is addressed to the heads of export-related industry associations and asks them to let member companies know they should consider drafting or reviewing a CP5. The preamble of the current CP filing notice ("On filing internal compliance programs," last amended April 9, 2025, effective May 9, 2025) says METI has accepted filings based on this 1994 notice6. The path to penalties runs through the compliance standards, not the notice. The Minister can give guidance and advice (Article 55-11) and issue recommendations and orders (Article 55-12), and breaching such an order is punishable by imprisonment of up to six months or a fine of up to ¥500,000 (Article 71, item 11)1.
The four officers on page 49 and the conditions for the transaction review officer
Chapter 4, I, 1 (3) of the Introductory Guidance (version 3.0, March 2026), under "Internal control system," sets out the roles and appointment of four officers (p. 49)3. The strength of the wording differs from officer to officer, so here they are as close to the original as I can render them.
| Officer | Role (original wording) | Appointment (original wording) |
|---|---|---|
| Chief officer | "Oversees export control across the company and bears final responsibility as a company" | "A person who represents the organization; in an ordinary company, the representative director must be designated as chief officer" |
| Classification officer | "Bears final responsibility for classification, that is, whether items fall under list controls" | "Companies that export as a business must appoint a classification officer." Appointing someone with knowledge of the goods or technology and the law "is recommended" |
| Transaction review officer | "Bears final responsibility for the transaction review, deciding whether to go ahead with a deal based on classification and end-use and end-user checks" | "A position that can judge independently of the exporting department (sales, etc.) is recommended." "Is expected to be chosen from among directors or similar" |
| Shipment control officer | "Bears final responsibility for shipment control, such as confirming identity" | "There is no rule requiring one, but appointing one is recommended." "Must be someone with authority to stop a shipment immediately" |
The transaction review officer entry contains two conditions of different strength. Choosing the officer from among directors or similar is "expected." Independence from sales is "recommended." The guidance gives reasons too: independence because "a fair judgment on whether to proceed is needed," and directors because "the organization makes the final decision on the deal." That difference matters when we look at how to combine roles in the next section.
Department roles are on page 48. The exporting department (sales, etc.) "collects information on end use and end users needed for the transaction review and confirms them together with the export control department." The export control department is the company's control tower for export control and also handles "transaction review, approval of deals, and license applications to METI"3. Sales gathers information. It does not make the call. The last step of the review procedure (STEP 3 on p. 42) says the decision on whether to proceed is made by preparing "⑤ Transaction Review Form" and "obtaining approval from the officer responsible for transaction review"3.
The CP Q&A fills in the details of who to choose2. Q13 says, based on the ministerial notice, that the CP chief officer is "the representative director," and gives the reasons: responsibility for ensuring compliance with FEFTA-related law, authority to order a halt to exports that may be illegal, and responsibility for investigating the cause of a violation, reporting to the authorities and building measures to prevent recurrence. It also gives an exception. Where it is difficult to choose from among representative directors, as in a company with committees under the Companies Act, the chief officer could be chosen from among representative executive officers, directors or executive officers who have that authority, responsibility and ability. In that case, the reasons and their appropriateness must be carefully considered and made clear through a board resolution or another appropriate procedure.
Q14 covers the final decision-maker in transaction reviews. It says the ministerial notice requests that "officers or above" serve as final decision-makers, and that where choosing from among directors is difficult, as in a company with committees, someone equivalent could be chosen from among executive officers. It closes by saying that "in either case, it is desirable that the final decision-maker be someone who can judge independently of sales"2. In both Q13 and Q14 the company with committees is given "for example," so the exception is not written as limited to that case. Under the current Companies Act, the companies that have executive officers and representative executive officers are companies with a nominating committee, etc. (Article 402(1) and Article 420(1))7.
Watch the wording, too. The original 1994 notice says "a director or above." Q14 describes the notice as requiring "officers or above." The glossary of the Q&A counts a notice dated March 3, 2006 as part of "the ministerial notice," and I have not yet been able to check the original of that 2006 notice. A director satisfies both wordings. If you want to make a corporate officer (shikkō yakuin, an internal title that is not a director under the Companies Act) the final decision-maker, that fits neither wording, so I recommend consulting METI's Security Export Inspection Office before writing it into your CP. The Q&A says the office gives advice on drafting or changing a CP from the drafting stage (Q4, Q9)2. As for the classification officer, Q36 says that for the classification officer field in the CL (the annual self-check list that CP filers submit), anyone inside the organization may be named with no restriction on department or title, and that whoever approves classification records must be included. Having a section manager on double duty serve as classification officer, while the final deal decision goes up to a director, follows naturally from that.
Replace siloed classification work with AI.
METI's FY2024 data shows 52% of foreign exchange law violations stem from classification errors. Download the TRAFEED product catalog covering features and rollout.
Combining roles in small and mid-sized companies, and delegating authority
The Introductory Guidance also has wording for companies that are short on people. The box for small and medium-sized companies on page 49 says that "where it is difficult to appoint each officer, the representative director may serve as both chief officer and transaction review officer, or the representative director may hold all officer roles," and adds that "it is important to carry this out responsibly as an organization." The similar box on page 48 asks companies that cannot organize each function as a department to make clear who does the work3. Article 2 of the compliance standards ordinance also allows the overall officer and the classification officer to be the same person4.
From these sources I have sorted the realistic setups into four patterns. The pattern names and the "fits" column are my own.
| Pattern | Chief officer (overall officer) | Transaction review officer | Classification officer | Fits (my view) | Basis and caveats |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Split | Representative director | A director not in charge of sales (e.g., administration) | You, or a section manager in engineering | Companies with several directors, one of whom is outside the sales line | The default on p. 49. The worked example (fictional Company A) in our CP outline uses this pattern |
| B Representative doubles | Representative director | Representative director | You | Companies with few directors | The small-company box on p. 49. If the representative director leads sales, record the reasons for each decision (my suggestion) |
| C Representative holds all | Representative director | Representative director | Representative director | Very small companies | P. 49. Article 2 of the ordinance also allows the overall officer and classification officer to be one person |
| D Exception | Representative executive officer, director or executive officer | Executive officer | You or similar | Companies with a nominating committee, etc., and others where choosing a representative director or director is difficult | The exceptions in Q13 and Q14. Carefully consider the reasons and appropriateness and make them clear by board resolution or similar (Q13) |
In every pattern, your seat is the same. As classification officer you approve classification records. When a counterparty check raises a concern, you stop the case, sort out the facts and the legal position, and bring it to the transaction review officer. You are not the one who decides.
There are three setups I would avoid. The first is a final decision-maker who is not a director, such as a sales manager or a section manager doing the job part-time. That matches neither "from among directors or similar" on page 49 nor "a director or above" in the ministerial notice. The second is a director who heads sales acting as final decision-maker. The director condition is met, but the recommendation on independence is not. The third is never deciding who decides, and settling each case among whoever is involved. METI's fiscal 2024 on-site inspections cite a case where the people involved, including staff and the chief officer, handled things case by case, so that roles and responsibilities were not clear as an organization, and asked the company to set out clear roles and responsibilities matching the real work in its internal rules (p. 8)8.
A note on pattern B. Since the Introductory Guidance offers it, having the representative director also serve as transaction review officer is fine in itself. But in some companies the representative director is the one leading the big sales negotiations. If so, I would set a procedure where you put the concern in writing and the representative director writes the reasons for the decision on the transaction review form. That gets you closer to the recommendation on independence.
Delegating final authority to staff
If the transaction review officer is a director, the obvious question is whether that director has to look at every case. For a company with dozens of quotes a month, having a director sign off on all of them is not realistic. The results of METI's fiscal 2024 on-site inspections are a useful guide here8.
METI carried out 86 on-site inspections in fiscal 2024 (82 of them at CP filers), 31 of them at small and medium-sized companies with 300 or fewer employees (p. 2). Transaction review drew more findings than any other item: 139 overall and 63 at small and medium-sized companies (pp. 3 and 4). In the summary of main findings, the transaction review entry says that "where the final decision-maker's authority is delegated, the delegation should be kept within an appropriate range, for example by limiting its scope and the delegates according to the sensitivity and number of deals" (p. 6). One of the specific cases describes a CP that named the export control officer as the final decision-maker for deals, while some list-controlled goods were in fact being approved by the export control department. The finding: "where final decision authority over deals is delegated, make the delegate and the scope of delegation clear and set this out in the rules" (p. 7).
I read that wording as contemplating delegation that is limited in scope and written into the rules. So here is the line I suggest. It is my proposal, not an official standard.
| Case | Final decision | Delegate? (my proposal) |
|---|---|---|
| Not list-controlled, and no concern on any of the five check items | You, within the delegated scope | Delegate, once the scope is written into the rules. Report the number and a list to the transaction review officer once a month |
| Any of the five items marked "yes" or "unknown" | Transaction review officer | Do not delegate |
| List-controlled (including license applications, use of bulk licenses, and exceptions that remove the license requirement) | Transaction review officer | Do not delegate |
| The counterparty is on the End User List, or an inform notice has been received | Transaction review officer (also report to the chief officer) | Do not delegate |
Delegating is not the same as skipping. Another case in the same inspection results involved repeat deals with the same goods, end use and end users. The company skipped transaction review on the strength of an annual review, and kept skipping it even when shipping under a bulk license. METI's finding was that when a bulk license is used, the company must judge whether the license applies, including checking exceptions, and carry out a transaction review for each export (p. 7)8. Q48 of the CP Q&A says end-user information does not usually change with every deal, so confirming end users each time is not necessarily required, but it still asks for a check when the agent changes and for periodic checks in continuing business2. Lightening the routine checks and lowering the level of the person who decides are two separate design choices. Keep them separate.
You can start the wording from Articles 2 (system and officers), 4 (transaction review) and 5 (license applications and exceptions) of our ten-article outline of an internal export compliance program for mid-sized companies (Word, in Japanese). Each article has draft text, fields to fill in, a worked example for a fictional Company A, and the matching item of the ordinance and page of the Introductory Guidance. The outline does not yet have a delegation clause, so add the table above as a paragraph of Article 4.
Who stops a concern case, and in what order it gets decided
The Introductory Guidance defines transaction review as the procedure of "confirming, from the end use of the goods or technology and the business of the end users, etc., that there is no security concern, and deciding whether to go ahead with the deal," and splits it into STEP 1 to STEP 4 (pp. 38 to 42)3. Mapped onto a company with a dual-role staff member, it becomes the six stages below. The stages and who does what are my own arrangement; the right-hand column gives the source pages.
| Stage | Who | What to do | What to keep | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Stop | Whoever notices (usually sales) | Do not move the quote or order forward; bring it to you. Shipping does not ship any case whose transaction review is not finished | The "yes" or "unknown" entries on the five-point sheet | Guidance p. 46 (before shipping, confirm that classification and transaction review are complete) |
| 2 Gather facts | You and sales | Written questions to the counterparty, public information, re-screening against the lists (including the list version and date) | Questions and answers, screening record, the evidence behind each check | Guidance p. 39; inspections p. 6 (keep the evidence, not just the checklist) |
| 3 Sort out the legal position | You (as classification officer) | List-control classification, fit with catch-all requirements (inform notice, end-use requirement, end-user requirement), whether a license is needed | A one-page analysis | Guidance pp. 10, 13 and 42 |
| 4 Decide | Transaction review officer | Look at the four certainties and decide to proceed (including with conditions), apply for a license, or decline. If unsure, consult METI | Approval on the transaction review form | Guidance pp. 38, 41 and 42 |
| 5 Carry out | You | If a license is needed, apply, and instruct shipping only after the license is in hand | The license, the shipping instruction | Guidance p. 42 (STEP 4), p. 45 (STEP 1) |
| 6 Report | Transaction review officer and you | If you find a violation or a risk of one, report to the chief officer, then to METI without delay | Record of the report | Ordinance Art. 1, item 2 (nu); Guidance p. 52 |
Stage 4 is where people get stuck. The key point is that the transaction review officer is not always free to choose between "ship" and "don't ship." If the item is list-controlled, a METI license is required unless an exception applies (p. 42). Even if it is not list-controlled, a license is required if a catch-all license requirement is met (same page)3. For example, where the end user is on the End User List, METI's notice says a license is required unless it is clear, from the end use and the terms and form of the deal, that the goods will not be used for developing weapons of mass destruction or conventional weapons. The notice covers cases such as exporting goods under item 16 of Appended Table 1 of the Export Trade Control Order to the regions in the right-hand column of that item9. A license is also required if you receive notice from the Minister that you should apply for one (an inform notice) (Guidance pp. 10 and 13)3. In those cases the officer's options narrow to two: apply for a license, or decline.
The officer earns their keep on cases where no requirement is met but a concern remains. Page 41 of the guidance lists four certainties that METI uses when reviewing license applications and asks companies to use them in their own reviews: that the goods or technology will reach the end user, that the end user will use them, that they will not be used for a concerning purpose, and that they will be properly managed3. Fill those four in one at a time and you will see what is missing. If something is missing, choose between proceeding with conditions and declining. As an example of a condition, page 40, in its examples of procedures to make information more reliable, mentions writing into the deal a right to terminate unconditionally or claim damages if military diversion, illicit resale or false information comes to light3. How to obtain a pledge is covered in my piece on end-user certificates and pledges. Page 42 asks for particular care with inquiries that come through overseas subsidiaries and similar routes. Page 38 says, "If you are unsure how to judge a transaction review, please consult METI"3. What to do when an inform notice arrives, and how to use advance consultation, are in my piece on inform notices.
Stage 1, stopping, needs real authority behind it. METI's analysis of fiscal 2024 violations includes a case where, partly because a delivery deadline was close, a staff member exported an item as non-controlled on their own judgment without the supervisor's confirmation. METI's comment: "the problem is a system in which staff can export on their own judgment without going through internal approval" (p. 11)10. The pressure runs the other way too. Stopping a deal that sales is pushing, with words alone, is hard for someone doing this part-time. Give the dual-role staff member written authority to put shipments and technology transfers on hold until a decision is made. Q13 of the CP Q&A lists "authority to order a halt to exports that may be illegal" as one of the chief officer's powers, and I think of this hold authority as handing the day-to-day part of that power to staff2.
Agreeing on timing also reduces friction with sales. My rule of thumb: you assemble the material within two business days of the case coming up, and the transaction review officer decides, or says what else is needed, within the next business day. That is not an official standard. If it looks like you will miss it, tell sales when to expect an answer.
The review record, and a request memo to management
A decision becomes the organization's decision only once it is recorded. The Introductory Guidance lists, among the export documents to keep, internal review documents such as "transaction review documents, including classification and end-use and end-user checks" (p. 55). Q50 of the CP Q&A also lists classification, customer review, end-user and end-use checks, and transaction review documents as internal review records. In the fiscal 2024 inspections, METI asked companies reviewing end users to "keep not only the checklist but also the evidence of the checks" (p. 6)328. Attachment 4 of the guidance includes sample forms such as "⑤ Transaction Review Form" and "⑦ List of Departments and Officers in Charge" (p. 57)3.
The table below shows the fields for a transaction review form, with a worked example. The company, product and dates in the example are all fictional.
| Field | What to write | Example (fictional case) |
|---|---|---|
| Case | Case number, counterparty, item, quantity, destination | 2026-118. Ten of our general-purpose measuring instruments to a new distributor in a country outside the regions in Appended Table 3 of the Export Trade Control Order |
| Classification | Classification record number and result | Not list-controlled (record 2026-031) |
| Concern | Which of the five items is "yes" or "unknown" | Item 4 (end user) unknown. Item 5 (anything unusual): quantity large for the distributor's size |
| What we checked | Questions and answers, list version and date, public information | November 18: written reply from the distributor (end users are two local parts makers; use is product quality inspection). November 19: distributor and both makers screened against the End User List (as amended on September 29, 2025) and the US Consolidated Screening List; no matches. Business of both makers confirmed on their websites |
| Legal position | Whether a license is needed, and why | No inform notice. Within the screening and replies, no facts meeting the end-use or end-user requirements of the WMD or conventional weapons catch-all controls; recorded as no license needed |
| Four certainties | Reaching the end user, use, no concerning use, management | Reaching and use: copies of the two makers' purchase orders to the distributor obtained. Quantity matches their inspection lines (five units each). Management: installation at the two makers' plants, per their reply |
| Conclusion and conditions | Proceed (with conditions), apply for a license, or decline | Proceed, on condition that the distributor gives a pledge stating the end users and end use and committing to notify us before any resale |
| Decided by, and when | Who, when, in what role | Director, Head of Administration (transaction review officer), November 20, 2026 |
| Next review | When, and what triggers it | The next order. The half-yearly re-screening of existing counterparties |
A word on re-screening frequency. My 30-day piece and our CP outline both re-screen existing counterparties against the lists every six months. That is my proposal, and it is stricter than the example the Introductory Guidance gives on page 40 among procedures to make information more reliable: "periodic checks of public information (for example, once a year)"3.
You can keep the screening record itself on the "screening record form" and "hit assessment" sheets of our counterparty screening record kit (Excel, in Japanese). It is built so you can answer, during an inspection, when you screened and against which version of which list.
Setting roles needs management's approval. The memo below is a draft for a company that has not yet named a transaction review officer. Adjust it to your situation and have legal review it before you use it.
Sample memo (to management: naming a transaction review officer and setting the scope of delegation) Subject: Request for approval: naming the final decision-maker for counterparty concern cases At present I, as classification officer, am in practice making the final call on cases where counterparty checks raise a concern. METI's Security Export Control Guidance [Introductory Edition] (p. 49) expects the transaction review officer to be chosen from among directors or similar, and recommends a position that can judge independently of sales. The ministerial notice on drafting and reviewing internal compliance rules also calls for a director or above to be the final decision-maker in transaction reviews. I would therefore ask you to approve four things. 1. That [name], a director not responsible for sales, be named transaction review officer (if that is difficult, the guidance also allows the representative director to take this on). 2. That, only for cases that are not list-controlled and raise no concern on any of the five items, checking and approval be delegated to me. The scope will be written into our rules as in the attachment, and I will report the number and a list every month. Cases with a concern, license applications and the use of exceptions will always go to the officer. 3. That I may put shipments and technology transfers on hold until a decision is made. 4. That [name] act as deputy when the officer is away. We expect about [X] quotes a month, of which about [Y] may raise a concern. In its fiscal 2024 on-site inspections, METI pointed out that where final decision authority is delegated, the scope and the delegates should be limited and the delegate and scope set out in the rules.
It also helps to fix, in advance, a short note to sales for when you put a case on hold.
Sample note (to sales: when a case is on hold) The [company] case is on hold for shipping and for confirming the quote until the transaction review officer decides, because the counterparty check did not identify the end user. Please ask the customer, in writing, for the end user's company name, address and intended use. Once the reply arrives, I will screen it, sort it out and take it to the officer. If this is likely to affect the delivery date, please let me know early.
The groundwork for that memo, with sample requests for naming the overall officer and classification officer and for giving authority to stop shipments, is on the "sample requests" sheet of our dual-role officer's 30-day plan (Excel, in Japanese). The "five-point counterparty check" sheet in the same file is where the "concern" field in the example above comes from.
Wrapping up, and what I have not been able to confirm
When a counterparty check raises a concern, whoever notices it stops the case, the dual-role staff member sorts it out, and a director or similar who is independent of sales decides. "Transaction review officer" is not a term in the compliance standards ordinance, but page 49 of the Introductory Guidance, paragraph (2)③ of the ministerial notice and Q14 of the CP Q&A all point the same way, and the arrangement carries over as is when you file a CP.
Three things to do on Monday morning. Check whether your role table has a line for the transaction review officer. If it does not, pick one of the four patterns above and send the request memo. Then write down, on one page, which cases are delegated to staff. Skip the third step and every case quietly goes back to being decided by one person on their own.
What I have not confirmed: I have not yet seen the original of the March 3, 2006 notice ("On strict implementation of security export control") that the CP Q&A counts as part of "the ministerial notice." I also cannot confirm whether the "officers or above" wording in Q14 comes from that notice. The Introductory Guidance does not define how far "directors or similar" extends. The delegation line and the timing rule of thumb are my proposals, not official standards. Individual cases should be decided by your own officer, consulting METI's Security Export Inspection Office where needed. According to page 58 of the Introductory Guidance, METI runs an outreach program for small and medium-sized companies that offers briefings, consultations and support for building export control systems free of charge3.
If you want counterparty screening and the decisions on concern cases kept in one place, TRAFEED can help. The final decision always rests with your company's export control officer.
What to read next
- The first 30 days of a dual-role job: the role table, the five-point sheet and the first request to management.
- Ten steps to build an export control system: from naming officers to the CP, training and audits.
- Counterparty due diligence in practice: how to do stage 2, gathering facts.
- Designing counterparty screening operations: name matching, false positives and keeping evidence.
- METI's "clearly not" guidelines: the sheet for judging when use for weapons development is clearly ruled out under the end-user requirement.
- The catch-all control revisions: the end-use, end-user and inform requirements you apply at stage 3.
- Preparing for METI's on-site inspections: a 30-item audit checklist.
Footnotes
-
Foreign Exchange and Foreign Trade Act, Article 55-10 (including paragraph 4), Article 55-11, Article 55-12 and Article 71, item 11 (in Japanese). Checked against the text retrieved on November 22, 2026 through the e-Gov Law API v2 (law ID 324AC0000000228; version in force from August 12, 2026, as amended by Act No. 64 of 2026). https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/324AC0000000228 ↩ ↩2
-
METI, "Q&A on 'On filing internal compliance programs'" (prepared May 2, 2025) (in Japanese). Glossary (definition of the ministerial notice), Q2, Q3 and note 2, Q4, Q9, Q13 and note, Q14, Q36, Q48 and Q50. Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 21, 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/compliance_programs_pdf/20250502_CPtutatsuQA.pdf ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9
-
METI, "Security Export Control Guidance [Introductory Edition]," version 3.0 (March 2026) (in Japanese). Chapter 4, I, 1 (2) on departments and the small-company box (p. 48); (3) on officers' roles and appointment and the small-company box (p. 49); 2 on drafting a CP (p. 50); 5 on reporting violations (p. 52); II, 3 on document management (p. 55); Chapter 3, III on transaction review (pp. 38 to 42); IV on shipment control (pp. 45 and 46); Chapter 2, III, 3 on catch-all controls (pp. 10 and 13); Attachment 4 (p. 57); outreach program (p. 58). Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 20, 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/guidance/guidance.pdf ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12 ↩13 ↩14 ↩15 ↩16
-
Ministerial Ordinance on Export Compliance Standards (METI Ordinance No. 60 of 2009), Article 1, item 1 (i) and (ro), Article 1, item 2 (i), (ro), (ni), (ho) and (nu), Article 2 and Article 4 (in Japanese). Version in force from October 9, 2025, as amended by METI Ordinance No. 41 of 2025. Checked against the text retrieved on November 22, 2026 through the e-Gov Law API v2 (law ID 421M60000400060), including that the word "transaction review" does not appear. https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/421M60000400060 ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
Minister of International Trade and Industry, "On drafting or reviewing internal rules for compliance with export-related laws in response to non-proliferation export control" (June 24, 1994, No. 6-Bō-604, addressed to heads of export-related associations), 3, (2)① ("set up an export control organization with the representative director as chief export control officer, and clarify the division of work and scope of responsibility") and (2)③ ("a director or above shall be the final decision-maker in transaction reviews of controlled goods, etc., and a system shall be put in place to prevent in advance the execution of deals where there is doubt as to whether export or provision is permissible") (in Japanese). Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 20, 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/law_document/tutatu/t06naibukitei/t06naibukitei_daijin.pdf ↩ ↩2
-
METI, "On filing internal compliance programs" (Export Notice 17 No. 9; last amended by Export Notice 2025 No. 10, issued April 9, 2025, effective May 9, 2025), preamble (in Japanese). Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 21, 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/compliance_programs_pdf/20250509yushutsukanrinaibukitei.pdf ↩
-
Companies Act, Article 2, items 11-2 and 12, Article 402(1) and Article 420(1) (in Japanese). Checked against the text retrieved on November 22, 2026 through the e-Gov Law API v2 (law ID 417AC0000000086; version in force from August 12, 2026). https://laws.e-gov.go.jp/law/417AC0000000086 ↩
-
METI Trade and Economic Security Bureau, Security Export Inspection Office, "Results of FEFTA compliance on-site inspections (security export control), fiscal 2024" (December 2025) (in Japanese). P. 2 (86 inspections, 82 at CP filers; 31 at small and medium-sized companies, defined as 300 or fewer employees), pp. 3 and 4 (transaction review findings: 139 overall, 63 at small and medium-sized companies), p. 6 (main findings on transaction review), p. 7 (specific cases on transaction review), p. 8 (specific case on roles and responsibilities). Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 21, 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/compliance_programs_pdf/rikken_r6.pdf ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
METI, "On the End User List" (No. 20250922-Bōkyoku-1, September 29, 2025, applied from October 9, 2025) (in Japanese). Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 20, 2026. METI's list of legal amendments (https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/law09-2.html , retrieved November 21, 2026) shows the September 29, 2025 amendment as the latest amendment of the End User List. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/20250929_2.pdf ↩
-
METI Security Export Inspection Office, "Analysis of FEFTA violation cases (security export control), fiscal 2024" (December 2025), p. 11, "(1) Violations relating to the management system" (in Japanese). Checked against the original retrieved from METI's website on November 20, 2026. https://www.meti.go.jp/policy/anpo/gaitameho_document/ihanjireigaitamehou6.pdf ↩






