(November 21, 2026) We corrected two points to match the Federal Register text: the claim that only the BIS rule reaches down an ownership chain, and the claim that 25%+ ownership still functions as a Red Flag while the BIS rule is stayed (the stay covers all of the rule's amendments, including Red Flag 29). We also corrected the de minimis thresholds (from "generally 10%; 0% for terrorism-supporting destinations" to "generally 25%; 10% for Country Group E:1 and E:2"), the MEU List countries (from "China, Russia, Venezuela" to the five countries in current § 744.21, with Russian and Belarusian military end users carried on the Entity List under footnote 3), and the record retention period (from "at least five years" to ten years for records under OFAC's rules).
(November 22, 2026) In the November 21 correction we wrote that Russian and Belarusian military end users are handled through Entity List footnote 3. We have revised this to match the text of § 744.21(a)(2): if you know an item is intended for a military end use in Russia or Belarus, or for a Russian or Belarusian military end user wherever located, a license is required for all items subject to the EAR. Only those military end users located outside Russia or Belarus are limited to entities on the Entity List with a footnote 3 designation.
Hello, this is Ryuta Hamamoto from TIMEWELL. One of the first questions new dual-hatted export-control owners ask me is: "What's the real difference between the Entity List and the SDN List?"
Both are U.S. restricted-party lists, but the agencies, the way restrictions attach, and the delisting procedures are different. Add the MEU List (Military End-User List), created in 2020, and you have the three lists every export-control and sanctions program needs as an entry point. List placement is a regulatory designation. It is not, by itself, a judgment that a company is a "bad actor."
Below I organize the differences and the typical ways Japanese companies get caught without realizing it, with tables and cases. By the end, a reader about six months into export control should be able to picture how to re-check their counterparty list.
What you will learn
- Differences across Entity List / MEU List / SDN List by agency, scope, and effect (one comparison table)
- Five ways your company can get caught (de minimis, FDP Rule, 50% rules, and more)
- Penalties and recent enforcement/settlement examples (including a ~$250 million settlement)
- Five practical steps (CSL match → 50% verification → end-use checks → internal controls → records)
- Common misconceptions / FAQ (unlisted affiliates; Affiliates Rule during suspension)
A fill-in screening procedure covering all five list systems: It maps where to look, what to check and how to record it for US OFAC, US BIS, the EU, the UK and the UN, plus Japan's Foreign End User List — including the 50% / ownership-control test, official source URLs and update cadence, and the Red Flags. You can turn the five steps in this article (CSL match, 50% verification, end-use checks, internal controls, records) into your own written procedure, and show it when a counterparty or an auditor asks how the screening was done. Listing is a regulatory classification, not a judgment about a company. → Download the Five Sanctions-List Systems Screening Procedure (2026) (Free; your company name and work email address are required.)
Three terms to understand first
U.S. restricted-party lists are numerous and hard to map at first glance. Start with how the big three fit.
Entity List
- Formal name: Entity List (EAR Supplement No. 4 to Part 744)
- Agency: Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS), U.S. Department of Commerce
- Role: Foreign persons, companies, and organizations that BIS has determined present a significant risk of involvement in activities contrary to U.S. national security or foreign policy interests (regulatory standard under the EAR; not a court finding of corporate guilt)
- Effect: Exports, re-exports, and in-country transfers of "items specified on the list entry" to that entity require a BIS individual license. License exceptions are generally unavailable; the license review policy is set entry by entry, and many entries carry a "Presumption of Denial"
- Entries: more than 3,400 (the figure BIS published as of September 2025)
The key point is license requirement, not an absolute ban. In theory a license can be granted; in practice approval is rare, so operationally the list often means "stop the deal."
MEU List (Military End-User List)
- Formal name: Military End-User List (EAR Supplement No. 7 to Part 744)
- Agency: BIS, U.S. Department of Commerce
- Role: Lists foreign parties identified as "military end users" of Burma, Cambodia, China, Nicaragua, or Venezuela (created December 23, 2020). Russia and Belarus are covered separately by § 744.21(a)(2): if you know an item is intended for a military end use in Russia or Belarus, or for a Russian or Belarusian military end user wherever located, a license is required for all items subject to the EAR. Russian and Belarusian military end users located outside those two countries are not on the MEU List; they are limited to entities on the Entity List with a footnote 3 designation. Again, this is a regulatory category under the EAR.
- Covered items: only certain ECCNs listed in EAR Supplement No. 2 to Part 744 (semiconductors, sensors, communications equipment, etc.)
- Feature: Within the five countries (Burma, Cambodia, China, Nicaragua and Venezuela), unlisted parties can still be covered if they meet the "military end user" definition; BIS states that supplement no. 7 is not an exhaustive listing of military end users in those countries. Military end users located outside the five countries are limited to entities on the MEU List (§ 744.21(a)(1))
The biggest difference from the Entity List is item scope. The Entity List can reach EAR-subject items broadly; the MEU List reaches only specified ECCNs. Geographic scope is also limited to the five countries in § 744.21(a)(1): Burma, Cambodia, China, Nicaragua, and Venezuela.
SDN List (Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons List)
- Formal name: Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons List
- Agency: Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC), U.S. Department of the Treasury
- Role: Lists parties designated under OFAC programs covering sanctioned jurisdictions, terrorism, narcotics trafficking, cybercrime, human-rights abuses, and related authorities
- Effect: (1) property in the United States is blocked, (2) U.S. persons (U.S. citizens, permanent residents, U.S. companies, persons in the United States) are generally prohibited from all transactions
- Secondary sanctions: Non-U.S. third-country companies dealing with SDNs can risk their own SDN listing or exclusion from U.S. markets
Among the three, the SDN List is the strictest. Unlike the Entity List's license model, it is a general ban across all goods and services plus asset blocking.
Replace siloed classification work with AI.
METI's FY2024 data shows 52% of foreign exchange law violations stem from classification errors. Download the TRAFEED product catalog covering features and rollout.
One table: the big three compared
| Item | Entity List | MEU List | SDN List |
|---|---|---|---|
| Agency | Commerce BIS | Commerce BIS | Treasury OFAC |
| Authority | EAR Part 744 | EAR § 744.21 | IEEPA and others + 31 CFR |
| Geography | Worldwide | Burma, Cambodia, China, Nicaragua, Venezuela (Russia and Belarus: § 744.21(a)(2); those outside the two countries are on the Entity List with footnote 3) | Worldwide |
| Nature of restriction | License (review policy set per entry; often Presumption of Denial) | License (specified ECCNs only) | General ban + asset blocking |
| Item scope | EAR items specified on the entry | Items in Supp. 2 to Part 744 | All transactions regardless of item |
| Reach outside the U.S. | EAR extraterritorial tools (de minimis, FDP Rule) | EAR extraterritorial tools | Secondary sanctions; 50% rule |
| Primary subjects | Anyone dealing in EAR items worldwide | Anyone dealing in EAR items worldwide | Primarily U.S. persons; non-U.S. persons via secondary sanctions |
| Civil penalty cap | Up to $374,474 per violation or twice the transaction value | Same (as EAR violation) | Up to ~$377,700 per violation or twice the transaction value |
| Criminal penalty cap | Up to 20 years + $1M per count for individuals | Same | Same |
| Delisting | Written petition to End-User Review Committee (ERC); unanimous | ERC | OFAC Reconsideration Petition; typically 1–3 years |
| Appeal | No administrative appeal; judicial review only | Same | Administrative reconsideration available |
Put differently: Entity List and MEU List belong to export control; SDN List belongs to economic sanctions. Japanese literature often mixes them. Separate them by statute and agency from day one.
CSL is only an entry point
Beyond the three, BIS runs the Denied Persons List (DPL) and Unverified List (UVL); OFAC runs Sectoral Sanctions Identifications (SSI); DDTC runs the Debarred List; and more. Consolidated Screening List (CSL) aggregates many of them; trade.gov provides free API and CSV feeds, updated daily at 5:00 a.m. EST.
Practitioners typically start with CSL, but CSL only hits listed parties. Unlisted affiliates that become blocked under the 50% rules (below) do not appear in CSL. That is the first trap for beginners.
Five ways your company can get caught
Many teams assume "we don't export to the United States, so Entity List is irrelevant." Domestic Japan deals and third-country deals can still be captured. Five patterns I see most often:
Pattern 1: Re-export of products above the U.S. content threshold (generally 25%) (de minimis Rule)
When foreign-made products incorporate controlled U.S.-origin content above the de minimis level (generally 25%; 10% for countries in Country Group E:1 or E:2), their reexport is subject to the EAR. For some items and destinations there is no de minimis level at all, so any U.S. content brings the item under the EAR (15 CFR 734.4(a)). Even products assembled in Japan can need a BIS license to re-export to Entity List parties if U.S. semiconductors or software exceed the threshold.
Pattern 2: Delivery of products made with U.S. equipment or technology (FDP Rule)
Under the Foreign-Produced Direct Product Rule, foreign-made products produced with U.S.-origin technology, software, or equipment can be EAR-subject. In semiconductor manufacturing equipment and AI-related items, Japanese-origin tools can still be captured once U.S. masks or U.S. EDA software are in the process. The eleven FDP paragraphs and their scope, including the carve-outs for Japan, are laid out in the FDPR and what Japanese firms miss.
Pattern 3: USD settlement with an SDN (U.S.-routed payments)
Even yen deals between Japanese companies can fall under OFAC if U.S. persons, U.S. products, or U.S.-routed funds are involved. Classic example: USD wires almost always transit U.S. correspondent accounts and thus U.S. jurisdiction.
Pattern 4: Deals with unlisted companies 50%+ owned by SDNs (OFAC 50% rule)
Under OFAC's 50% rule, unlisted companies that an SDN (or certain blocked persons) owns directly or indirectly, alone or in the aggregate, at 50% or more are automatically blocked. Critically, CSL will not surface them. You must research ownership separately.
Pattern 5: China subsidiaries selling EAR items to military end users (MEU List)
Even if Japan HQ never exports, a China subsidiary selling EAR items to parties that meet the military end-user definition onshore creates MEU List risk. MEU List is not only "is the name listed?" but also "does the counterparty meet the military end-user definition?" Local end-use diligence is essential.
Two 50% rule systems
As of November 21, 2026, the OFAC and BIS versions are in different operational states.
| Rule | Agency | Content | Status as of November 21, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| OFAC 50% Rule | Treasury OFAC | Unlisted companies 50%+ owned (direct/indirect, alone/aggregate) by SDNs or certain blocked persons are automatically blocked | In force (clarified since 2014) |
| BIS Affiliates Rule | Commerce BIS | Same EAR restrictions as the parent Entity List / MEU List entity automatically apply to unlisted foreign entities 50%+ owned (direct/indirect, alone/aggregate) | Effective 2025/9/29 → stayed from 2025/11/10 (originally through 2026/11/9) → extended on 2026/11/9 through 2027/1/10 (91 FR 70789) |
Both rules look at ownership, aggregated directly and indirectly, at 50% or more, and both reach down a chain: if A owns B and B owns C, C can be covered (see how the 50% rules aggregate indirect ownership). The difference is the effect. OFAC's rule blocks the entity's property; the BIS rule applies the same license requirements as the listed parent. Ownership or control below 50% does not trigger automatic blocking under OFAC's rule, although OFAC urges caution because such entities may be designated in the future.
The BIS Affiliates Rule has been stayed since November 10, 2025, and on November 9, 2026 the stay was extended through January 10, 2027 (91 FR 70789). The stay covers all of the September 2025 rule's amendments to parts 732, 734, 736, 744 and 748, including the new Red Flag 29 (the duty to resolve unknown ownership percentages). The Entity List itself remains in force. Because the stay runs only to January 10, it is prudent to map the ownership of counterparties in which listed parties hold stakes now (our recommendation). Details: Complete guide to the BIS Affiliates Rule (50% rule).
Violation risk
EAR and OFAC penalties are roughly comparable and inflation-adjusted annually. 2026 caps:
- EAR (Entity List / MEU List): civil up to $374,474 per violation or twice the transaction value, whichever is higher; criminal for individuals up to 20 years + $1,000,000 per count
- OFAC (SDN List): civil up to about $377,700 per violation or twice the transaction value; criminal for individuals up to 20 years + $1,000,000 per count
- Administrative: EAR violations can also strip export privileges (Denied Persons List). DPL is a full ban on EAR-item dealings and is the strictest of BIS's three lists
Three recent examples, stated as settlements or public enforcement facts (settlement does not by itself equal a court finding of guilt):
- Semiconductor manufacturing equipment maker (announced February 2026): a major equipment maker settled with BIS for about $250 million in civil penalties over re-exports to Entity List parties via subsidiaries. Settlement resolves the matter by agreement and does not itself adjudicate guilt as a formal finding
- HDD maker (2023): a major HDD maker settled with BIS for about $300 million where FDP Rule application was at issue
- Consumer-goods company (2023): a company settled with OFAC and DOJ for about $629 million over North Korea–related sanctions laws
Recent Entity List expansions have reached operators in dual-use fields such as semiconductors, AI, quantum, hypersonics, and drones. The 32 additions in September 2025 have been analyzed by law firms as related to those fields and third-country routing. Listing is a regulatory classification, not a judgment of corporate wrongdoing.
Five practical steps
What to do starting tomorrow:
Step 1: Screen counterparties and end users on CSL
- Match names, addresses, and aliases on trade.gov's Consolidated Screening List
- Watch name variants (Chinese pinyin / traditional / simplified; Russian Cyrillic / Latin)
- Re-screen monthly or before each deal even after a clean hit
Step 2: Verify 50% rules (ownership)
- For major counterparties, walk one level up shareholders, parents, and affiliates
- Check whether SDN / Entity List parties own 50%+ directly or indirectly, alone or aggregated
- Even below 50%, if you find a significant stake held by a listed party or overlapping officers, dig deeper and record what you found (our recommendation)
- Use domestic data (Teikoku Databank, Tokyo Shoko Research) plus foreign registries (OpenCorporates, etc.)
Step 3: Confirm end use and end user
- Military, national police, intelligence, or research-institute involvement (MEU List context)
- Interview whether final use could involve WMD or military end uses
- Obtain End-Use Statements and conduct site audits as needed
Step 4: Build internal controls (CP)
- Document pre-deal screening, in-deal monitoring, and post-deal records
- Separate screener and approver; apply four-eyes principle
- Clarify reporting lines to management
Step 5: Retain records and prepare for voluntary disclosure
- Keep screening results, ownership checks, and decision memos. The minimum is five years for EAR records (15 CFR 762.6) and ten years for records of transactions subject to OFAC's rules (31 CFR 501.601)
- If a violation is discovered, immediately consider Voluntary Self-Disclosure (VSD)
- U.S. authorities operate near strict liability. "We didn't know" is not a defense; VSD can substantially reduce civil penalties
Common misconceptions / FAQ
Q1. If a subsidiary is not on CSL, is the deal fine?
A. Not safe.
- OFAC 50% rule automatically blocks unlisted companies 50%+ owned by SDNs
- BIS Affiliates Rule (stayed; the stay was extended on November 9, 2026 through January 10, 2027) applies the same restrictions to unlisted foreign entities 50%+ owned by Entity List / MEU List parties
- Below 50%, counterparties in which listed parties hold significant stakes or control still call for careful checks (OFAC urges caution because they may be designated in the future)
Use CSL as an entry point and pair it with ownership-chain research.
Q2. BIS Affiliates Rule took effect September 29, 2025. What happened?
A. A one-year stay took effect on November 10, 2025. The stay was originally set to end November 9, 2026, but on that day BIS published a rule extending it through January 10, 2027 (91 FR 70789; updated November 20, 2026), and absent a further rule the rule applies again after that date.
During the stay, the amendments including Red Flag 29 are not in effect (the DATES section of 90 FR 50857 stays the amendments to part 732 and the other parts). The Entity List itself still applies, and the stay runs only to January 10, 2027. "Suspended" does not mean "do nothing"; treat the period as time to map ownership before the rule may come back.
Q3. Which is stricter, Entity List or SDN List?
A. As a general matter, SDN List is stricter.
- SDN List: general ban across items + asset blocking
- Entity List: license requirement for specified items (review policy set per entry; often Presumption of Denial)
But Entity List entries with Footnote 1 (certain well-known listed entities in the communications/equipment space) or Footnote 5 can pull in foreign-made products broadly via the FDP Rule and approach SDN-level impact. Always check footnotes on each Entity List entry. Placement remains a regulatory status.
Q4. A counterparty name appeared on the Entity List. Stop immediately?
A. Before stopping, check:
- Whether the deal items fall within that entry's License Requirement Column
- Whether the transaction is EAR-jurisdictional (de minimis / FDP Rule)
- Whether a license application is viable (check the entry's review policy; you can still apply under a Presumption of Denial)
For SDN List hits involving U.S. persons, stopping is the starting point. OFAC General or Specific Licenses may still apply. Involve counsel.
Q5. We dealt with a listed party without knowing. Now what?
A. Near strict liability. Lack of knowledge is not a defense.
- Upon discovery, consider VSD promptly; large civil-penalty reductions are available
- Records of pre-export screening (CSL, ownership checks) can mitigate
- Contact U.S. counsel and Japanese export-control advisors immediately
July 2026: the Japan–India summit
Big-three screening is U.S.-origin, but Japan’s economic-security framework is also moving. At the Japan–India summit in Delhi on July 2, 2026, the two governments issued the Japan–India Joint Declaration on Economic Security Cooperation, committing to project-based cooperation in five priority areas: semiconductors, critical minerals, information and communications technology, clean energy and pharmaceuticals. The two leaders also welcomed that about ¥2 trillion of investment had already been decided toward the ¥10 trillion private investment target set in 2025 (Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, "Japan-India Summit Meeting and Luncheon," July 2, 2026, in Japanese). At the joint press announcement, Prime Minister Takaichi said both countries regard strengthening supply chains for critical goods as an urgent task (Visit to India (2), joint press announcement, Prime Minister's Office of Japan, July 2, 2026, in Japanese). As supply chains reconfigure, counterparties and end users change. New suppliers are exactly when Entity List / MEU / SDN first screening and ownership checks matter most. Background: Japan–India Summit 2026 and economic security.
Key takeaways
If you only do one thing tomorrow, re-screen major counterparties on CSL and walk ownership one level up. One more pass on the big three:
- Entity List: Commerce BIS; license-based; specified items; worldwide; 3,400+ entries
- MEU List: Commerce BIS; license-based; specified ECCNs only; Burma, Cambodia, China, Nicaragua, Venezuela (Russia and Belarus are covered by § 744.21(a)(2); those outside the two countries are on the Entity List with footnote 3); definition-based coverage even if unlisted
- SDN List: Treasury OFAC; general ban + asset blocking; all items; strict for U.S.-person dealings + secondary sanctions
Five typical Japanese-company capture patterns:
- Re-export of products above the U.S. content threshold (generally 25%) (de minimis Rule)
- Delivery of products made with U.S. equipment or technology (FDP Rule)
- USD settlement with SDNs (U.S.-routed payments)
- Deals with unlisted companies 50%+ owned by SDN / Entity List parties (50% rules)
- Subsidiaries in China and other covered countries selling EAR items to military end users (MEU List)
Operational minimum: CSL match, 50% verification, end-use checks, internal controls, record retention.
Related articles
- Complete guide to the BIS Affiliates Rule (50% rule): deep dive on the rule, its stay deadline, and the published extension
- EAR Affiliate Rule risk: risk scenarios for Japanese companies
- End-user screening and customer due diligence: screening operations primer
- What Is an ECCN? A Short Primer: item-side determination
- Deemed export risk guide: technology transfers to foreign persons in the U.S.
If you want big-three list matching and ownership checks under the 50% rule to run as a routine process, you can contact us about TRAFEED. An overview of its features is in the TRAFEED service catalog (PDF).
References
U.S. government (official)
- BIS: Entity List and other lists
- BIS: EAR Part 744 full text
- eCFR: 15 CFR § 744.16 Entity List
- eCFR: 15 CFR § 744.21 MEU restrictions ((a)(1) Burma, Cambodia, China, Nicaragua, Venezuela; (a)(2) Belarus, Russia; checked November 21, 2026)
- eCFR: 15 CFR § 734.4 De minimis U.S. content ((c) 10%, (d) 25%; checked November 21, 2026)
- eCFR: 31 CFR § 501.601 Records and recordkeeping requirements (at least 10 years)
- OFAC: SDN List search
- OFAC: 50% rule FAQ
- OFAC: SDN removal petition procedures
- ITA: Consolidated Screening List
- Federal Register: Affiliates Rule final (September 30, 2025)
- Federal Register: Affiliates Rule one-year suspension (November 12, 2025)
Japanese government and support bodies
- METI Security Trade Control Guidance (introductory)
- CISTEC Export control fundamentals
- JETRO Business news (U.S. export controls)
Law-firm analysis (2026 practice)
- White & Case “BIS implements Affiliates Rule”
- Sidley Austin “BIS Adopts 50 Percent Rule”
- Morrison & Foerster “BIS Adopts 50% Affiliates Rule”
- Baker McKenzie “BIS Introduces New Affiliates Rule”





